My All-Star Ballot
2010 marks the first year that I've had the privilege of voting as a media member for the MLS All-Star Game. Media voting marks 25% of the total vote count for the roster, so it's nice for this community to have just a bit more influence than normal.
Last week, Denz from RSL Soapbox wrote about the conundrum that we bloggers face between voting as media members and as fans. Well I don't share any of his mixed emotions.
Black And Red United is indiscreetly a fan blog. That's what it says on my front banner. I don't claim to be an unbiased journalist, as that actually goes against the entire concept behind the SB Nation network.
So what I'm getting at is this: I voted my heart.
D.C. United sitting just a point out of last place in the Eastern Conference isn't going to stop me from voting for some of the team's players to go to Houston to take on Manchester United on July 28th.
But even with the biased nature of my voting habits, I still voted for more L.A. Galaxy players than United players. The captain of our team shared his votes earlier, mine are after the break.
Goalkeeper: Donovan Ricketts (LA Galaxy). This was not a difficult decision as he has allowed by far the fewest goals this season of any starting goalie, and already has nine clean sheets to his name.
Defenders: Omar Gonzalez (LA), Bobby Boswell (Houston Dynamo), Jamison Olave (Real Salt Lake). In just his second season, Gonzalez is a legitimate contender for MLS Defender of the Year. Boswell has been the anchor of Houston's defense every match this season, and is still a favorite of mine. Olave single-handedly kept United off the scoreboard when RSL visited last month.
Midfielders: Chris Pontius (DC), Andy Najar (DC), Clyde Simms (DC), Marco Pappa (Chicago Fire), Dwayne De Rosario (Toronto FC). Here's where my homerism comes in. His stats don't quite show it all the time, but Pontius is well on his way to being among the top American players in the league. Najar is just an enigma, and keep in mind that I sent in my votes the day that I received the ballot (couldn't wait - it was like Christmas morning!), which was before I soured on him a bit. With Shalrie Joseph bouncing in and out of the Revolution's lineup, Simms is worth consideration as one of the top defensive midfielders in the league. The final two choices are a bit more obvious, as Pappa and DeRo are in direct competion for the award of "Most Valuable Player Not On The Galaxy."
Forwards: Edson Buddle (LA), Landon Donovan (LA). The league leaders in goals and assists definitely deserve to start, while other deserving candidates Juan Pablo Angel and Alvaro Saborio will be left out of the lineup thanks to MLS's odd decision to include Donovan as a forward instead of a midfielder.
How did I do as the voting representative of this community? Feel free to post your own votes below.
Tweet
7 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
How about Julius James
Jackovic has played great too, but he missed quite a few games with his injury.
by dc army on Jul 11, 2025 11:42 PM EDT via mobile reply actions
Hey now, you're an all star
DC has had a poor season, doubt we’ll see many all-stars…
by Irrlicht on Jul 12, 2025 9:42 AM EDT reply actions
nothing wrong
in being totally unabashed in your fandom, like I said I voted for a number of RSL players both on my fan ballots (which I voted several times a day) and my media ballot. I however couldn’t vote for guys who simply don’t have a chance. Like voting for Perot.
by denz on Jul 13, 2025 12:19 AM EDT reply actions
Hate being forced to chose a 352
There’s no way Arena starts a team in that formation, making the voting inherently flawed.
Nonetheless, here are the guys I’d have voted for:
GK: Donovan Ricketts There isn’t much of an argument for anyone else.
DF: Jamison Olave Still as athletic as ever, but now making fewer inexplicable bonehead plays.
DF: Omar Gonzalez Monster season. He’s developed so much faster than I expected, and I already had high hopes after watching him so often at Maryland.
DF: Todd Dunivant You barely ever hear his name, but Dunivant has been a constant source of solid, intelligent play for the Galaxy.
RM: Marco Pappa Not really his best position, but you’ve got to fit him in somewhere. Without him, Chicago would be no better than those of us bunched up at the bottom.
DM: Clyde Simms My homer pick. That shouldn’t completely discredit Simms, though, because he has gone above and beyond since returning from his early-season injury. He also did a pretty good job last week of neutralizing…
CM: Joel Lindpere Angel gets all the attention, but NY’s most consistent player is definitely Lindpere.
AM: David Ferreira I’d list him 3rd on my MVP ballot at this stage of the season. Outstanding player in good form, deserves much more attention.
LM: Dwayne De Rosario Another player that I’m listing out of position. If not for Donovan, he’d be the easy pick for MVP right now.
FW: Landon Donovan You’ve got to pick him, even though he’s played maybe 1 game this season up front. MVP at this point in the season.
FW: Edson Buddle No surprise here. 10 goals, and he missed over a month for the World Cup!
Bench: Nick Rimando, Chad Marshall, Drew Moor, Michael Stephens, Daniel Hernandez, Steve Zakuani, Javier Morales, Sebastien Le Toux, Guillermo Barros Schelotto, Alvaro Saborio
by ChestRockwell on Jul 13, 2025 7:56 AM EDT reply actions
Because defenders aren't trendy
They don’t suspect that fans will know who to pick for defenders, so they go with the 3 vs. the should be 4. It is like listing Landycakes as a forward, he isn’t and shouldn’t have been listed there, but it allows them to ensure he gets the spot.
by denz on Jul 13, 2025 4:23 PM EDT up reply actions
I know why it is
I just don’t like it. MLS has been doing this since the 90s, and it’s been stupid the whole time.
by ChestRockwell on Jul 13, 2025 7:06 PM EDT up reply actions
So who would you say has been DCU’s single best player so far in 2010? Simms?
"My face is my mask."
by Jake Shapiro on Jul 13, 2025 3:32 PM EDT reply actions

by Martin Shatzer on 






