Black And Red United: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook

SuperDraft SuperConjecture SuperFuntime!

Building on Chest's channeling of Professor Trelawney, comes this from OregonLive's Geoffrey Arnold: Darlington Nagbe might not want to play in the Great White North.  Or at least not in Vancouver.

Obviously, this leads to speculation - supported by talk last week that they were open to the idea - that the Whitecaps might look to trade the pick.  Obviously, the good writers here at B&RU have already considered what DC might give to get at that top spot, and they've gone in depth at who to take at United's current #3 draft slot.

But what if we could have our Charm City Cake and eat it too?  Assume that United trades some player or future draft pick or money or something else to Vancouver in exchange for the #1 pick on Thursday; and further assume that whatever United gives up, the FO somehow manages to hold onto the third pick.

So now we get to play with two picks in the top three.  My questions to you, good people of the Internet:

 

  1. Who do you take #1? Please limit your responses to "Nagbe" and "Kitchen" for the sake of realism.
  2. Who do you think Portland takes at #2?
  3. Who do you take #3?

Me?  I go Kitchen first.  He seems like the best talent in the draft, and I don't like drafting for need, at least not in soccer.  There's also the off-chance that Portland goes with Valentin or another non-forward with the second pick, creating the almost incomprehensible scenario of one team drafting both Kitchen and Nagbe.  Of course, that team happens to be our Boys in Black.
(And for those curious:  Yes, this entire FanPost is an exercise in getting too excited over the draft and pretending that the best case scenario is at all likely.  Improbable? Definitely. Unfeasible? Quite possibly. Humor me.)

Tweet Comment 11 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

I'm excited that we have another pick in the draft now from trading Cristman

It’s something more I get to see and do in Baltimore on Thursday!

by Brendanukkah on Jan 11, 2026 10:36 AM EST reply actions  

Actually...

It’s a supplemental draft pick. Which means it won’t go down until the league conference call next week.

by The AMT on Jan 11, 2026 10:53 AM EST up reply actions  

Darn

That’s not nearly as exciting. For some reason, I was reading this as the 16th overall pick in the draft, which I thought was a great haul.

by Brendanukkah on Jan 11, 2026 11:55 AM EST up reply actions  

I think that would have been Brucing the Bruce.

And nobody Bruces the Bruce. Not even our Benny.

by The AMT on Jan 11, 2026 12:16 PM EST up reply actions  

In the words of Antonio Banderas, "let's play"

This won’t happen. Then again, I once mis-hit a golf ball in my backyard while drunkenly practicing chip shots (you do dumb things in college, like hit golf balls towards your own house). The resulting “chip” would have actually made a decent mid-range shot. Somehow, against all odds and in totally unrepeatable fashion, it went through an open window into my roommate’s room, hit an empty spot on the wall, and broke nothing.

In other words, maybe we fall ass-backwards into a dream scenario.

1. I’d take Nagbe. It’s a great situation where our need dovetails with arguably the best talent in the draft. As good as Kitchen is and will become, I don’t see a situation in which he becomes a starter for at least 3 years. Simms is 28, meaning he’s in his prime years as a player. McCarty is just 23; he could be a stalwart in a United shirt for years to come. Kitchen is a destroyer, which means that if McCarty were unavailable, our best option to maintain the closest replica of the best DCU 11 would be to insert King instead. Kitchen is probably right there with Salgado in terms of ceiling as a player, but how do you reach that ceiling if you’re sitting the bench for the first 2-3 years of your career?

Now, if that Simms trade rumor is legit, then obviously Kitchen becomes both a “want” and a “need.” Until then, though, I say we take Nagbe and plan on him having a Mwanga-esque 2011.

2. Portland would take Kitchen at #2. Looking at their squad, both Nagbe and Kitchen would be immediate starters for them. The central midfield for the Timbers includes a couple of two-way guys (Lowry and Moffat) and one pure destroyer (Marcelin, who simply isn’t good enough with the ball to be relied upon as a starter). Spencer would probably prefer to have an attacking midfielder or forward of Kitchen’s potential and current ability out there, but that player doesn’t exist.

3. This is the toughest one. With Nagbe in place as a probable starter, I think we’d be foolish not to consider thinking long-term with a riskier pick like Salgado or Plata. On the other hand, with the Cristman trade we don’t have much in the way of aerial strength. Pontius has real hops, and Ngwenya is no slouch, but neither is going to outmuscle your bigger center backs for crosses (assuming that we will somehow be able to cross the ball next season, even though I declared to a friend that DCU in 2010 was “the worst crossing team I’ve ever seen”). If you want the next Braun or Ching, Will Bruin is the pick.

However, since I still have doubts about our ability to cross with regular success, I think our best chances will be generated on the ground. As such, and with Nagbe in place, I’d take Salgado at #3. I’d then immediately ask Josh Wolff to show Salgado how to become a good pro. Salgado would be a fixture on the reserve team, and would get minutes in the Open Cup and friendlies (and that’s a conservative estimate). By 2013, provided he avoids major injury and gets the proper guidance, we’re looking at a potential star.

by ChestRockwell on Jan 11, 2026 12:49 PM EST reply actions  

Whatevs

Andy Najar totes beat Omar Gonzalez for a headed goal.

by Brendanukkah on Jan 11, 2026 1:29 PM EST up reply actions  

Najar is playing by a different set of rules

Other, less special players are bound by things like physics and gravity.

by ChestRockwell on Jan 11, 2026 3:18 PM EST up reply actions  

I would take Darlington Nagbe with the #1 pick.
Portland will take Perry Kitchen @ #2.
Then I’d grab Jalil Anibaba at #3.

We’d get our offensive forward with Nagbe. Dynamic. Quick. Could be the perfect foil for Najar. * drool *. Then I think we take a defensive stud with the 3rd pick, rather than rolling the dice with Omar Salgado or Joao Plata (or Will Bruin, for that matter). Although, if we go with a second forward with the #3 pick, the choice is clearly Salgado. In the end, I stick with my offense/defense choice. With Nagbe and Anibaba, we’d get two solid picks that I think will be impact players this year in MLS, and for years to come.

by madavis on Jan 12, 2026 11:37 PM EST reply actions  

The reverse of this would be to go defense, then offense. DCU takes Kitchen #1. Portland takes Nagbe #2. DCU takes Will Bruin #3…. probably the top 3 picks off the board tomorrow no matter which team is drafting.

by madavis on Jan 12, 2026 11:39 PM EST up reply actions  

Another Scenario

I love the idea of snagging Nagbe and Salgado with the #1 and #3 picks. Another possibility is we give up Pontius and the #3 pick in return for the #1 and the #8 picks from Vancouver. Nagbe and then Salgado would still be a possibility if that scenario played out.

As Chest mentioned, if Simms were traded we’d be taking Kitchen. I would think we could still get Salgado or Hertzog with the #8 pick, but Bruin would probably be gone by then.

And for what its worth (not much I know), It pisses me off these Johnny Come Lately teams from the northwest stole our number one pick, dammit. We earned that pick with one of the crappiest years of soccer ever played in MLS. Here’s to reclaiming what’s rightfully ours.

by JaimeSegundo on Jan 12, 2026 11:41 PM EST reply actions  

I thought the same thing…. of all the years to have expansion teams come in! I wish they would have held a lottery with DCU, Portland, and Vancouver to see who gets the #1, 2, and 3 picks. At least give us a chance at the #1 pick we earned through much pain and suffering.

I’ve also changed my mind. Screw the defense. I take Nagbe #1 and Salgado #3.

by madavis on Jan 12, 2026 11:55 PM EST up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation fan blog in support of D.C. United!

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Where in Ft. Lauderdale is training camp?
Dsc00683_small
Strikers???
Dsc00683_small
Supplemental draft
Fedora_small
SuperDraft SuperConjecture SuperFuntime!
What, If Anything, Does The MSA Report Tell Us About A New D.C. United Stadium?
Happyhanukkah_small
Danny Allsopp goes waltzing Matilda

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

SBNation.com Recent Stories

+1 updates

Fedor Vs. Silva Results: Press Conference And Post-Fight Notes

+2 updates

Villanova Vs. Pitt: Panthers Hang On For 57-54 Win At The Pavillion

Photo +14 updates

Strikeforce: Fedor Emelianenko Vs. Antonio Silva Results And Live Play-By-Play

More from SBNation.com >


Managers

Martin2_small Martin Shatzer

Authors

Hbsc_small ChestRockwell

Fedora_small The AMT