Black And Red United: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook

DC United defeat FC Dallas, are no longer the most disappointing team in DC

Adam Cristman celebrates his two goal performance with his teammates.  Photo via dcunited.com

Adam Cristman celebrates his two goal performance with his teammates. Photo via dcunited.com

Out of the two Washington DC based teams with tournament games tonight, I think many of us probably would have preferred the other one to win.  But DC United gave the nation's capital something to be hopeful for with their Open Cup play-in game victory over FC Dallas 4-2.

In a battle of two winless teams, United made their presense felt from the opening whistle, and for the first time this season were able to keep that pressure on for the entire match.

Is this finally the start of something good?  Follow me down below the break for player ratings and conclusions.  I'll keep it short since I'm only working off of highlights, your own previous comments, and the thoughts of a trusted colleague.

Star-divide

The team played well as a unit, but there were two players that stood out in this match more than any other United players all season.  Adam Cristman and Andy Najar combined on two of the team's goals, and Cristman added one more with the help of the recovering Clyde Simms.  Najar's hard work was evident, and now has the national MLS blogosphere singing his praises.  Cristman's clean finishing on both goals gives DC something they were lacking in their first four league matches.

Maybe the very most important thing that came out of this match was Christian Castillo's goal.  It wasn't pretty.  I don't think it was even meant as a shot.  But hopefully this tally will give Castillo the confidence he's been sorely lacking in his previous appearances for us.  Castillo seems to be well suited for the 4-2-3-1 lineup that United used in this match.

It was difficult to get too much of a read on the defenders based on the highlights, but I put a lot of faith in my commenters, so I'll take your word for it that Devon McTavish was rather solid.  Not that its a big deal, but I was surprised to hear that Talley, in only his second month with United, was wearing the captain's armband ahead of McTavish, who is in his fifth year with the club and typically wears it for reserve matches.

I think we've all got some mixed feelings on Rodney Wallace right about now.  We've been desperately hoping to see him continue to make progress as a left back.  During the first four regular season games, he was arguably the most consistent defender on a backline thats given up more goals than any other MLS team.  So maybe thats not saying much.  But he seems to have taken a step back in this one.  Hopeully it was just one bad game and not too much cause for concern.

Jordan Graye on the other hand didn't really have many redeeming qualities.  Onalfo giving Graye the start on the right ahead of Lyle Adams wouldn't have been my choice.  Fortunately for United, they were able to score enough goals in this match that giving up two soft ones didn't matter too much.

***

Advancing through the first play-in game of a tournament that's traditionally taken pretty lightly shouldn't be seen as a monumental victory.  But goddamn its good to finally see some positive signs from this team!  Its been over a month since I've had the chance to write anything optimistic about DC United.  Thankfully we have another match just three days away to try to continue this momentum.

And suddenly Curt Onalfo is going to have some tough decisions to make.  Its not highly likely that newly reacquired Luciano Emilio will be ready to start, but I can see a debate coming on the merits of Cristman versus Emilio, with a little Allsopp thrown in there for good measure.

Also, how about that 4-2-3-1?  A formation that may sound familiar to avid followers of the DCU|FM Challenge, it seemed to work in this setting, giving Najar and Castillo a bit more freedom with two more defensive minded midfielders behind them.  Is this viable though long term?

Tweet Comment 27 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

More from Black And Red United

Scouting Report: Houston

May 2010 by ChestRockwell - 2 comments

DC United lose to Colorado Rapids, continue to lack chemistry

May 2010 by Martin Shatzer - 11 comments

Scouting report: Colorado

May 2010 by ChestRockwell - 2 comments

GameThread: Colorado Rapids at DC United

May 2010 by Martin Shatzer - 7 comments

How many is too many? (A reprise)

May 2010 by Martin Shatzer - 8 comments

Around SB Nation

Seattle Sounders' Three-Year Window - It started in 2010

Feb 2011 from Sounder At Heart - 14 comments

Non-League Day Match Review: FC Dallas vs Toronto FC

Sep 2010 from Coming Home Newcastle - 1 comment

Teaching Timbers: An American League Playing an International Sport

Dec 2010 from Stumptown Footy - 42 comments

Rodney Wallace: Was He Worth It?

Nov 2010 from Stumptown Footy - 1 comment

Timbers Trade Cronin and Allocation Money for DCU's Troy Perkins

Dec 2010 from Stumptown Footy - 4 comments

Comments

Display:

Time to turn all my sporting attention to DCU!

"My face is my mask."

by Jake Shapiro on Apr 28, 2025 11:31 PM EDT reply actions  

New striker combo

Najar and Cristman worked wonders together. I know they’ve brought in Emilio to add punch to a previously punchless offense, but they could do worse than to give the Najar-Cristman front-line a chance in league play.

The defense is still highly suspect — especially Rodney Wallace, who shows no signs of ever becoming a competent defender — but, Perkins played better and Simms has returned.

A win over NYRB would make a lot of things start to look better.

by fischy on Apr 28, 2025 11:40 PM EDT reply actions  

This was probably the best I've seen United play all year

No one looked very bad tonight, and there were good games (from my untrained eye at any rate) from Najar, Castillo, Christman, and Talley.

One thing that I’d like to address was Curt Onalfo’s ejection. Talley had made some innocuous tackle that looked tough but mostly clean, and was whistled for a foul. He took exception and had some harsh words for the referee. Then Onalfo came over and started yelling at the ref to call the fucking game, and telling him to go fuck himself. Since the stadium was so empty, I could hear Curt pretty clearly, and it surprised me because everything I’ve heard is how he’s so positive and upbeat. Well, Curt got run, and part of me is thinking he did it to fire up the team. United has lacked spark all season, so why not try showing some passion from the bench? Honestly, it was the first thing this season that really impressed me about Onalfo.

A couple minutes later, the Barra started up with their “We’re all in Onalfo’s Army” chant, which I loved. It was the first time I’d heard it all season, and took it as a sign that maybe we were starting to embrace our coach. Look at how fired up he is! He got tossed for us, so let’s win the game for him! But then they started chanting, “Ben-ny Ol-sen!” and I realized they hadn’t declared themselves part of Onalfo’s Army; they were part of Benny’s Army. Since Olsen was now presumably in charge for the rest of the match.

I gotta say, that really disappointed me. I love Benny as much as any fan, and I’ve been as discouraged with Onalfo as any fan. But it’s still only been four games, and he’s still our head coach. He finally did something that made me, as a fan, want to follow him, and our loudest supporters are throwing him under the bus and cheering for some other guy. That doesn’t really speak to the kind of “support” that I want to give my team.

by Brendanukkah on Apr 29, 2025 12:25 AM EDT reply actions  

To be fair, they do the Ben chant any time he’s about to do anything (come on, come off, or take over, as the case may be). But I’m only speaking from experience, and wasn’t there tonight. Prolly should have been, in retrospect.

They're coming.

by Bald Pollack on Apr 29, 2025 12:35 AM EDT up reply actions  

This was definitely because Benny was in charge (probably) after Onalfo got sent off

My friend confirmed at halftime that they had been chanting “We’re all part of Benny’s Army.” And when I joined the Barra and the Eagles in the second half, they did the same thing.

by Brendanukkah on Apr 29, 2025 1:45 AM EDT up reply actions  

The problem with that is that Kris Kelderman, not Olsen, is Onalfo’s top assistant. And that makes sense; Kelderman has a 2.5 season head start on Benny as a full-fledged coach.

by ChestRockwell on Apr 29, 2025 11:36 PM EDT up reply actions  

A few thoughts

1. Onalfo got sent off fairly early - which means the assistant coaches took over. Which means, effectively, that Ben Olsen was our head coach for close to 60 minutes.

Also for the record - I was in the Supporters section when we started the Army song, and it was more funny than anything else - I think it DID start off as Onalfo, and then we all kind of realized at the same time that Olsen was arguably our head coach at that point in the game. The “awkward high-school crush” that the Eagles and Barra have on Benny lends itself to such things. Plus, the simple mechanics of it - “we’re all IN Onalfo’s” is still trying to take root while “we’re all PART OF Tommy’s/Benny’s” is still stuck. I heard some people singing for Tommy on accident.

I agree with the fight shown by Onalfo and I’m glad that he showed some, but honestly I had no idea he had been sent off until I saw something about it on Twitter (which I was checking for Caps updates). Of course, I also liked his post-game reaction to the Caps loss (he was apparently incredulous) - it’s nice when DC teams support each other.

2. Andy Najar is absolutely the real deal. One play in particular (other than the deft chip over the Dallas back line to set up Cristman’s 1st goal): Dallas guy is trying to shepherd the ball out for a goal kick, and Najar reverse-nutmegs him to steal the ball away and take it toward the goal for a cross. Nothing more came of it, but DAMN that was a nice piece of skill. And he’s 17.

3. Boyzzz Khumalo had several plays where he really could’ve played a nice through-ball for Najar, Cristman, or Castillo, and instead he kept his head down and either tried a terrible cross or back-passed it. And the forwards were calling for the through-ball. Perhaps this is why he does not start, among other things.

4. Jordan Graye was getting absolutely schooled by Brek Shea. I’d also note that our back line consisted of a single “ideal” starter - Wallace, and he didn’t play very well. McTavish had a good game, however.

5. Hartman: Thanks for the gift.

I had forgotten what winning feels like.

It feels really good.

by VercengetorixII on Apr 29, 2025 12:39 AM EDT reply actions  

There were a couple of times that Najar just basically stole the ball from one of the Dallas players

I was really pleased to see that. You can see him getting better with each game. He’s not afraid to fight either, and I was impressed with how often he would jockey for position and win. Of course, the next moment, the Dallas player would push him off the ball, so he’s still got some growing to do.

by Brendanukkah on Apr 29, 2025 1:47 AM EDT up reply actions  

asdf

Hard to know what Graye was thinking, since he was deliberately letting Shea behind him and trying to play catch-up when the ball came in. Was he the only one playing an offside trap? After the third or fourth time he was burned, McTavish and a couple of others laid into him. Graye also kept passing the ball far too weakly, causing havoc for his ‘mates. Wallace looked even worse on defense, though he had some good runs down the side. Graye will learn, I think. I’m beginning to wonder about whether Wallace will ever be a good defender.

On the plus side — Cristman was very effective. My favorite moment was when he took a pass off his chest and held control juggling the ball, before passing it. If he can play like that in a league game, he should have a place in the starting lineup. Totally agree with your observations on Najar, which was why we were actually applauding that effort.

by fischy on Apr 29, 2025 10:55 AM EDT up reply actions  

Graye

Keep in mind this was his first meaningful game. Thought he settled down and had some nice moves and a few great runs, he’s nice and big too and will learn to use that size

by Irrlicht on Apr 29, 2025 1:43 PM EDT up reply actions  

One of the Dallas center backs didn't have a name or number on the back of his shirt

Should that tarnish our victory? HELL NO! But it bears mentioning.

by Brendanukkah on Apr 29, 2025 1:48 AM EDT reply actions  

Cristman

First off, we got a win. Finally. Sure it wasn’t league play, but it was Open Cup play against an MLS team, which is worth something; and though it’s lacking prestige, the Open Cup is a good step to more international exposure. And if for nothing else, last night’s win may give United some much needed confidence to keep their chins up in the challenging schedule ahead. The defense could’ve looked better, but they’re still knee-deep in injuries. For his part, Troy Perkins looked much better too. Najar had a great night also - without a doubt.

I think it’s worth noting that Adam Cristman’s showing last night should come as little surprise - after all, the guy was a finalist for MLS Rookie of the Year a few years ago. He was a 4-year starter for a solid Virginia squad, he has quite a bit of national team experience including some international goals, and he made solid contributions to the Revolution as a starter alongside Twellman and Ralston when they last won the Open Cup and made it to the MLS Finals.

He’s looked strong coming off recent injuries (which were undoubtedly the reason he’s missed so much playing time) and I really think this guy deserves a closer look as a regular starter. He’s a workhorse forward that has plenty of speed and strength, and his first touch shows some quality finesse. He was making intelligent passes, working off the ball like a madman, and creating opportunities like a seasoned leader. Not to mention, last night’s performance of 2 goals and an assist showed the kind of hunger that United has been lacking this season. As far as I’m concerned, this guy deserves should be given a lot more chances on this team.

by break away on Apr 29, 2025 2:34 PM EDT reply actions  

Cristman’s kind of clumsy, and Dallas would have had to work pretty hard to do a worse job marking him.

That said, he took his 2 goals well. Hell, he scored 2 goals, period. On this team, that’ s enough to see a major boost in minutes regardless of Emilio’s return and Allsopp’s quick recovery. There’s no way the Allsopp we’ve seen thus far scores either of Cristman’s goals.

Cristman did exactly what any 4th string forward should do when thrust into the team: He gave his coach a very difficult decision to make for the weekend.

Cristman’s lack of technical ability concerns me, but then sometimes you need a less technical approach to mesh with your teammates. Look at Barcelona with Ibrahimovic instead of Eto’o. Their attack was unstoppable last year in part because they had all these wizards on the ball, and they’re playing with a guy that relies much more on speed and avoiding his marker than anything else. You need to find that kind of blend, so that the genius can rely on the athlete, and the powerhouse can rely on the guy with rockets in his boots, etc. Last year, we could have used a lot more of the more simple game Cristman plays to go with Moreno and Gomez trying to amaze and astound every time they had the ball. There’s beauty in the ugly side of the game, too.

by ChestRockwell on Apr 29, 2025 11:44 PM EDT up reply actions  

Some good points there and also in your post below, Chest - I shared similar complaints about Emilio and Allsopp. Ibrahimovic is a really good example too. I could see Cristman occupy a similar role for United in the future. To that end, though I’ve heard the complaint before, I disagree that Cristman’s “technical ability” is concerning. This really just seems like a category error - I think the concern evaporates when you think about it in a different way. I realize he’s been relegated to sub status for much of his time w/ United, but I actually think Cristman is much better than a 4th stringer when you consider his intended role on the field.

To me, “technical ability” is a vacuous phrase that refers to any number of things about a player. What is meant by “technical ability”? First touch, ability to dribble through numerous opponents, shielding skills, vision of field, distribution skills, repertoire of fancy tricks, finishing technique, ability in the air, creativity in high pressure situations, etc? As far as I’m concerned, all these things make up a player’s “technical abilities”, but they’re all very different aspects of play. So when someone worries about the “technical ability” of a player like Cristman, I think I know what they mean, but I also think they’ve missed a crucial point: players have different roles and each role requires specific skills. First, which aspect of the player’s “technical ability” is concerning? And second, is that concern relevant to the player’s specific role on the field? Cristman has a good first touch, plays simply and directly, finishes well, wins most of his air challenges, and keeps a breakneck tempo that creates space for the more “technical” players. Of course he’s not “technical” like Moreno or Castillo, but then again he’s not supposed to be. I think the question should really be: does he possess the technical abilities United requires of a workhorse forward? I think that’s a “yes”.

by break away on Apr 30, 2025 12:22 PM EDT up reply actions  

Cristman's technical ability

He looked like he has some pretty good ball skills for a guy of his size and build. He was juggling the ball to control it on one play. His goals showed great touch and awareness.

by fischy on Apr 30, 2025 6:17 PM EDT up reply actions  

Whenever I talk about technical ability, I mean skill with the ball. Touch, passing, ability to keep the ball in tight spaces, shooting, etc.

Cristman did show a decent first touch, but will it be consistent? Can Cristman regularly make the required pass after holding the ball up? If he draws 2 markers while on the ball, can he make the right touches to keep them from stripping him of the ball?

I see what you’re saying. A guy like Marvell Wynne doesn’t really need to be able to hit an inch-perfect lob over a defender to a moving target 10 yards away. Certainly Cristman doesn’t need to be the second coming of Etcheverry; demanding that would be silly. However, by my definition of technical ability, I think the jury is still out on him. He did look better than I remembered him being. His finishes were both moderately difficult chances to take. I stand by my concerns; they’re concerns, after all, not deal-breakers. Can he do the job required? Yes, it’s possible. Will he? I don’t know. I hope so, because this team needs to improve up top regardless of what kind of player we’re talking about.

by ChestRockwell on Apr 30, 2025 7:59 PM EDT up reply actions  

Is there video of the game?

Or am I SOL since I missed it yesterday?

Detroit4Lyfe

by handsomerob1 on Apr 29, 2025 3:07 PM EDT reply actions  

Check the Goffblog.

by The AMT on Apr 29, 2025 3:56 PM EDT reply actions  

That was supposed to be in reply to Handsome Rob, whom I’ve never seen, so I can’t comment on his handle.

by The AMT on Apr 29, 2025 3:57 PM EDT up reply actions  

4231

Is it viable? I’m not sure. Dallas struggles to defend with their A team, and this was the B side. Najar was up against Alexander, for example; will he succeed against guys like Alonso or Birchall (who, going off topic for a second, is playing superbly and getting no attention)? What about pairings like Mastroeni and Larentowicz? I liked what he provided on the night, but this will probably be one of the easiest games to play attacking midfield that we’ll see all season.

I think we’ll see a 442/4231 hybrid in the short term, with Moreno as the withdrawn forward/attacking midfielder. Quaranta and Castillo can be given more offensive freedom with Simms coming back, and I think we’ve got to find a way to keep Barklage’s energy in games (especially when the other option is Morsink, who still can be neutralized by simple high pressure). A big factor, to me, was that Cristman was more effective than Allsopp has been in terms of leading the line and holding the ball up. Those are huge factors for everyone else underneath him. Just like last year’s team played at half-speed because Emilio doesn’t offer speed or size and needs 10 years to make the right decision on the ball, this year’s team has suffered because Allsopp hasn’t meshed with the team and Pontius is in poor form as a forward.

by ChestRockwell on Apr 29, 2025 11:52 PM EDT reply actions  

About Rodney Wallace

Shatz wrote above: "During the first four regular season games, he was arguably the most consistent defender on a backline thats given up more goals than any other MLS team. "
-————————-

This would be true, if you meant consistently poor. I don’t know what you’re watching, but he’s been pretty bad. Our defensive left side has been a sieve. You’d be hard-pressed to recall any defensive stops or tackles that Wallace made, other than earning a yellow card or two. James and Talley have had bad moments, too — but I thing they’ve played some defense. Wallace’s effort on Wednesday was just plain awful, as he twice set up Dallas goals with really badly directed headers. I know a lot of people seem to think highly of him. He does have an extra gear when he dribbles that creates some excitement, but his defensive shortcomings are so much bigger.

by fischy on Apr 30, 2025 12:12 PM EDT reply actions  

true

I think Wallace is more of a winger in the league if he makes it. Definitely attack minded and not a good enough defender. Doesn’t Lyle Adams play that side?

by Irrlicht on Apr 30, 2025 1:33 PM EDT up reply actions  

Maybe, but not for his

He and Tiyi Shipalane were waived today.

by Brendanukkah on Apr 30, 2025 5:46 PM EDT up reply actions  

sigh..

there goes my next great hope for a Boswell part 2— defender out of nowhere

by Irrlicht on Apr 30, 2025 8:57 PM EDT up reply actions  

I don’t think he’s been quite as bad as you’re saying, fischy, but he has not been very good in my eyes. Further along than I was expecting (and, I’d argue, no worse than Burch’s regular showings), but still in need of work.

I think a big factor here is the fact that every game has seen a different back four. Wallace is learning this position at the pro level; he needs to be surrounded by stability. With Simms coming back, the back four will be under less pressure. Pena’s return is coming soon. As these pieces fall into place, we’ll get a more complete picture of what Wallace is capable of. Until then, I don’t think there’s a better option on the roster.

by ChestRockwell on Apr 30, 2025 8:06 PM EDT up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation fan blog in support of D.C. United!

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Where in Ft. Lauderdale is training camp?
Dsc00683_small
Strikers???
Dsc00683_small
Supplemental draft
Fedora_small
SuperDraft SuperConjecture SuperFuntime!
What, If Anything, Does The MSA Report Tell Us About A New D.C. United Stadium?
Happyhanukkah_small
Danny Allsopp goes waltzing Matilda

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

SBNation.com Recent Stories

+1 updates

Fedor Vs. Silva Results: Press Conference And Post-Fight Notes

+2 updates

Villanova Vs. Pitt: Panthers Hang On For 57-54 Win At The Pavillion

Photo +14 updates

Strikeforce: Fedor Emelianenko Vs. Antonio Silva Results And Live Play-By-Play

More from SBNation.com >


Managers

Martin2_small Martin Shatzer

Authors

Hbsc_small ChestRockwell

Fedora_small The AMT