DC United Defeats Real Salt Lake as the Legend of Andy Najar Grows
It seems like we've gone the entire season so far without a poorly officiated match. I don't tend to make a habit of complaining about officiating, but I sure did do it a lot last season. That hadn't been the case for DC United though this year.
Until tonight.
For the first 20 minutes of this match, tonight's referee failed to call a single foul, despite some very tough challenges. That set the tone of the match, and that's fine, as long as it's consistent. But then for a six minute period from 75' to 81', the referee called two very weak handballs in the box. Afterwards, he went back to calling nothing.
The first call that resulted in Luciano Emilio's penalty kick goal was difficult to see. But the second handball call came off a cross that hit Barry Rice's shoulder, while his arms were at his sides. If the referee hadn't made the first call, and Real Salt Lake hadn't complained so vociferously, there's no way the second call gets made. That was the classic case of a make-up call. And there's no room for that kind of crap in this sport.
Luckily for all of us, in the end, the two calls balanced out, and the match went into overtime anyway. I wanted to get into the officiating first tonight before diving more into the general aspects of the match because I feel like the poor officiating is going to get lost in the stories of other reporters, and forgotten by most fans.
There's a good reason for that. The reason is that something else happened in this match that we won't forget. There was a moment that every DC United fan watching is bound to remember for years to come.

Despite playing only 15 out of 120 minutes (12.5% of the match), there is no doubt that rookie midfielder Andy Najar was the man of the match. He came on the field at the start of the second overtime period and immediately started calling for the ball. It didn't take long for his teammates to get it to him. In the 107th minute, the ball found its way to Andy's feet, with two RSL players and a goalkeeper between him and the net. Najar cut, he spun, he danced, and he put the ball behind the two defenders, ran onto it, and knocked it past Kyle Reynish. It was one of those plays when the moment it happened, you knew it was historic. There are very few moments like that in sports. They only come about once every season. But this was definitely of them.
Troy Perkins went for much of the uneventful first half unchallenged, but he managed to turn away every ball, and made some crucial saves later in the match that were vital to United earning the victory.

The backline of Julius James, Barry Rice, Jordan Graye, and Devon McTavish did well to hold Real Salt Lake scoreless besides Will Johnson's penalty kick. James, clearly the leader, made at least half a dozen possession-changing tackles. Rice, while technically at fault on the penalty kick call, continues to impress with his ability to win headers, and made a possible game-saving clearance off the goalline in the second overtime period. Graye's speed was on display many times in this match on both ends of the field, and McTavish held his ground despite being frequently challenged by Fabian Espindola for the final 60 minutes.
Our central midfield pairing of Stephen King and Kurt Morsink worked hard throughout the match, doing exactly what was asked of them. Neither player was flashy, but both made an impact while playing the full 120. Similarly, Thabiso Khumalo had his best match of the season for United, often being the only player making attacking runs in the first 60 minutes of the match.

Other than his penalty kick goal, I didn't see a whole lot out of Luciano Emilio to justify keeping him around once his short term contract expires. He was like a black hole for much of the 90 minutes he played. Every attacking opportunity was slowed as soon as Emilio touched the ball.

Chris Pontius is allowed to have a bad night every once in a while. His frequent turnovers were discouraging. Let's hope that Pontius will be back to his normal form when given the start on Saturday night. He did well though once we took the lead to help waste time and kill off the match.
The most disappointing player tonight though had to be Jaime Moreno. He appeared slow and predictable, and failed to leave his mark on the match.
***
DC United is on once again to the US Open Cup's round of 16, where they will have to take on some lower division soccer clubs in the most important matches of their seasons. Always a dangerous situation.
In the mean time though, DC United now has three wins in a row in separate competitions, all coming at RFK Stadium. They'll get the chance to extend that streak to four later this week against the very same opponent. RSL is undefeated in five straight league matches, but United should be encouraged that they were able to shut out their opponents' three most talented attacking players in Javier Morales, Alvaro Saborio, and Espindola. If they can do that again on Saturday night, the league will really start to take notice of DC's ascent.
Tweet
15 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
It’ll be really interesting to see how both teams change their game up on Saturday. And I assume there’ll be a different referee? I don’t know how the officiating schedule works.
"My face is my mask."
by Jake Shapiro on Jun 2, 2025 11:07 PM EDT reply actions
Najar was definitely the MOTM. He was an automatic game changer. He is so confident with the ball at his feet.
by DonCaps819 on Jun 2, 2025 11:42 PM EDT reply actions
Najar's goal took my breath away. The kid is legit
Jaime has been pretty poor the last few times I’ve seen him. Ken Griffey, Jr. just retired today in the middle of a season because he could no longer cut it. Something to think about.
by Brendanukkah on Jun 3, 2025 12:30 AM EDT reply actions
I had to go out and change the sprinker for the yard (got new grass yesterday) when the goal happened. Pissed, then doubly so when I saw it online and how good it was.
They're coming.
by Bald Pollack on Jun 3, 2025 9:34 AM EDT up reply actions
That just means you should spend all of Saturday night outside playing with your sprinklers.
by Martin Shatzer on Jun 3, 2025 3:32 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions
I actually missed the goal too. The one time during the game that I switched over to the Stanley Cup Finals for about three minutes, Najar scores.
"My face is my mask."
by Jake Shapiro on Jun 3, 2025 5:57 PM EDT up reply actions
Pontius, Castillo, Luci/Jaime, the kid
Pontius looked like he was trying to do too much.
Castillo kept calling for the ball and waving his arms when he didn’t get it. (a la Freddy) When he did get it, he either passed back or did crazy stepover moves then hit a weak cross.
Luci and Jaime both looked really, really, really slow out there.
Najar— wow. Any chance he could be rookie of the year?
by Irrlicht on Jun 3, 2025 5:05 PM EDT reply actions
I thought a few weeks ago that it looked like Moreno didn’t trust Castillo enough to give him the ball when an attack was promising. Now, it looks like Moreno’s not alone in that regard.
by ChestRockwell on Jun 4, 2025 1:57 AM EDT up reply actions
I remember that play and I was thinking the same thing. Really a dubious sign for Castillo.
This just reminded me of Moreno’s goal in our home opener against TFC two years ago. Moreno actually stole the ball away from his own teammate Franco Niell in the box. Niell didn’t look like he even knew what to do with the ball once he got in the box. Jaime did. Jaime scored.
by Martin Shatzer on Jun 4, 2025 8:46 AM EDT via mobile up reply actions
I’m pretty much in agreement with Shatz here. I thought the refereeing was poor all night long towards both teams. We got away with a couple fouls, and Borchers should have been booked for his preposterous hockey check on Khumalo that ended up being given as an RSL throw (the ref was even well-placed to see that Borchers arrived well after the ball was gone). I guess when he sucks for both teams, it’s not as big a deal.
The Najar goal was definitely one of those special moments. One thing I’d like to add is that, on the loud side at least, there was a palpable excitement the moment Najar faced up against Beltran. Once it was clear he was going to attempt to dribble his way into the box, it was the same kind of electricity in the air that you’d get when Etcheverry stood over a free kick, or when Moreno would slow things down for just a moment at the top of the box a few years ago. The crowd seemed to know that something special was suddenly much more possible than it normally is, and that proved accurate.
Perkins played pretty well, though he did go casual on one save that slipped through his fingers despite being of only average velocity. I think Perkins was already thinking ahead to his throw out to start another attack. Still, to take his quote from that recent interview with Charles Boehm, he kept the ball out of the net there and every other time save the PK. I don’t think he’s back, but he’s getting there.
The back four definitely earned their high marks. It was never going to be flawless when McTavish had possibly as many MLS minutes as the rest of the group combined, but they made it difficult for RSL all night. There was a bit too much “when in doubt, kick it out,” but if it’s choosing between that and coping with our previous style of defense, I’ll take it. And it’s good timing, since the Deseret News scooped our local news sources in reporting that Talley has a possible concussion. After their showings of late, Onalfo would have had a hard time leaving James and Rice out anyway. Now, you’d have to expect James to step in alongside Pena (with Rice making the 18).
I was a little less happy with the midfield than Shatz. Not by much, but a little. Khumalo brought his typical attacking energy, but RSL had too easy of a time forcing him to go where they wanted. He also blew the breakaway that should have put us 1-0 up in the first half. Morsink did look better than normal tonight, but he was still too casual with the ball. I was glad to see him mostly focused on doing his job as our deepest midfielder (with a bad ref and his argumentative nature, this was a surprise), but he’s still got a lot of improving to do when we’re transitioning from defense to offense.
Emilio and Moreno just don’t strike me as a compatible partnership. Emilio spent the whole night trying to score and nothing else. Obviously goals are his meal ticket, but you’d better believe those Mexican coaches he wants to impress will notice that he contributed little other than the PK and one 30 yard shot (that should have been a pass, since we had RSL in a bit of trouble). There’s also the lack of athleticism between the two. You can get away with one guy like that, but two at the same time? McKenzie and Borchers are not speedsters by any definition, but the only person to burst past them was Khumalo. If Onalfo’s going to use these two players, it can’t be at the same time.
Quaranta and Pontius showed maturity and were very much in charge of how we managed the last 13+ minutes, even if Pontius had struggled when the game was still 1-1. That’s good to see. The group we had on the field during that 2nd half of OT was very young (average age: 24) compared to RSL’s more experienced late subs. It was difficult when RSL started piling forward and hitting us with a barrage of crosses, but earlier this year I don’t think we cope with the same situation with the same level of maturity.
by ChestRockwell on Jun 4, 2025 2:24 AM EDT reply actions 1 recs
Nice pull on the Talley link. Hopefully Jakovic is close to going (or at least can appear in the 18), and agreed on James and Rice. Quaranta’s looking more comfortable in the midfield, or at least has in the last couple of games.
They're coming.
by Bald Pollack on Jun 4, 2025 7:54 AM EDT up reply actions
Quaranta’s been playing the Moreno role, wandering underneath a target man. He’s had plenty of time to learn how to do that best, and he’s had a good rapport with Moreno for years, so I have hopes that it’ll work over time. With Najar and Pontius on the wings and King partnering Simms, playing Tino anywhere else would mean putting on a lesser player up top.
by ChestRockwell on Jun 4, 2025 8:20 PM EDT up reply actions
Moreno and Emilio
Yeah this wasn’t the lineup I wanted to see.
Had we lost, I had a much different match review in mind. I was looking for us to adopt more of a hard working and aggressive style in this one against the mostly inexperienced RSL backline and goalkeeper. That would have meant Allsopp and Cristman starting at forward (with a possible Emilio-Quaranta pairing on Saturday), and Najar playing the entire match.
by Martin Shatzer on Jun 4, 2025 9:10 AM EDT via mobile up reply actions
On the plus side, though, we won and we get a fresh Allsopp and a not-spent Quaranta for the league game. That’s got to be seen as a positive. Really, most of our current best team should be fresh (or fresh enough). Graye and King might have a hard time pushing through after 120 minutes Wednesday, and James is the likely replacement for Talley, but after that you’ve got Hamid, Pena, Wallace, Simms, and Allsopp who didn’t play at all, Najar only playing 15 minutes, and Pontius and Quaranta only went about an hour (with 2 breaks thrown in).
Compare that to RSL, who had to call on Russell, Borchers, Beltran, and Johnson for 120, Alexandre for 90, and Grabavoy, Espindola, Morales, and Saborio for an hour. With their injuries, they’re going to have to call on most of those guys to play major minutes tomorrow night.
We should look to push the tempo. Normally RSL’s fitness is never in question, but I think we have a chance to push them physically and cause them problems.
by ChestRockwell on Jun 4, 2025 8:48 PM EDT up reply actions
I can't be too hard on the scoop, since Goff is in South Africa
But another concussion? Of freaking course.
by Brendanukkah on Jun 4, 2025 9:57 AM EDT up reply actions

by Martin Shatzer on 







