Black And Red United: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook

What to do with Rodney Wallace

Rodney Wallace - photo courtesy of Matt Mathai

With DC United acquiring Christian Castillo on loan last month, we’ve been left to wonder what the team will do with their incumbent left midfielder Rodney Wallace. Many have suggested that Wallace should be United’s new left back, but its hard to say if that is necessarily the best place for him. Here are the three possibilities:

Left Back – Over the past several years for DC United, the left back position has been known as one of  the weakest links on the team’s roster. You could even say that the team has lacked consistency at this position since they traded away Mike Petke in 2005. The default starter over the past three seasons has been Marc Burch, but Burch is far from a consistent, and the team has obviously not been very satisfied with his performance either, having brought in Gonzalo Martinez to attempt to fill that role in 2008, and drafting a left back out of Maryland in 2009.

That left back out of Maryland goes by the name of Rodney Wallace, but despite playing that position in college, Wallace has yet to receive much of a chance in the back line in the pros. By my recollection, he only started one match at left back during the 2009 season, and was not impressive enough to win that role. Wallace has shined on the left side of midfield, but is he ready for the additional responsibility of the left back position?

Central Midfield – When Clyde Simms was out with a hernia injury midway through the 2009 season, and then again when Simms was moved temporarily to central defense, Rodney Wallace filled in adequately at Simms’ defensive midfield position. He may not have had the same vision and positioning as Simms, but his speed and aggression was a great asset to the team. The question here is how many central midfield slots will be available in 2010. When United played in a 3-5-2 formation or in a sort of flat 4-4-2 last year, they often utilized two central midfielders. Simms was the mainstay, and will continue to be, while the other spot was typically filled by either Ben Olsen or Andrew Jacobson. With both of these players now off the roster, the team is likely to look to Danny Szetela to step up. Might there also be room though for Wallace to get into this rotation?

Left Midfield – So Christian Castillo is here. So what? With three goals and three assists from this position last year, it’s hard to argue that Wallace really deserves to lose his job. And as many have said, Castillo is far from a sure thing. So if Rodney Wallace had no problem beating out the incumbent Fred for a starting role at left wing early in 2009, who’s to say that he won’t beat out Castillo also?

Poll
Where do you think Rodney Wallace should line up?
Left Back
43 votes
Central Midfield
7 votes
Left Midfield
11 votes

61 votes | Poll has closed

Tweet Comment 11 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

More from Black And Red United

Scouting Report: Houston

May 2010 by ChestRockwell - 2 comments

DC United lose to Colorado Rapids, continue to lack chemistry

May 2010 by Martin Shatzer - 11 comments

Scouting report: Colorado

May 2010 by ChestRockwell - 2 comments

GameThread: Colorado Rapids at DC United

May 2010 by Martin Shatzer - 7 comments

How many is too many? (A reprise)

May 2010 by Martin Shatzer - 8 comments

Week 7 SBNhanced MLS Power Rankings

May 2010 by Martin Shatzer - 5 comments

Around SB Nation

Rodney Wallace: Was He Worth It?

Nov 2010 from Stumptown Footy - 1 comment

Timbers Trade Cronin and Allocation Money for DCU's Troy Perkins

Dec 2010 from Stumptown Footy - 4 comments

Dynamo "Cruz" to Victory over DC United

May 2010 from Dynamo Theory - 0 comments

Comments

Display:

I’m on the record as being very strongly in favor of moving Wallace to left back. He’ll be no worse than Burch in terms of positioning, but will add more speed, mobility, and overall athleticism. I think he makes us much less predictable going forward, and I also think he’ll do better 1v1 in the back. As time goes on, he’ll improve at all of those things; has Burch improved as a left back at all in his time here? I mean, if Castillo comes in and really struggles, then we’ll have to look at moving Wallace there and recalling Burch. However, until that bears out, I would be floored if Onalfo didn’t roll with Wallace at left back and Castillo at left midfield.

My memory of Wallace’s use in all these positions was that it was pretty much exclusively down to needing him in a particular spot. This makes me desperately wish I had access to my painstakingly-kept records of DC’s lineups and formations (stupid old computer not booting up).

What I’m sure of is that Wallace started the season at left midfield in the 3412, which was pretty much the ideal position for him. When Olsen was banged up or needed a rest, Wallace was used in his central spot because he was the player most able to mimic Olsen’s particular brand of midfield play (combining some technique with a physically aggressive, dynamic approach). He spent very little time at left back, but it was again down to need; his one start was, I think, with Burch at center back or suspended. He was also shifted to the left side of a back three in a game where we were chasing a tying goal. He did an adequate job both times, but was moved elsewhere because another hole opened. I don’t think it was a matter of him not winning the job as much as him being needed elsewhere in Soehn’s eyes.

by ChestRockwell on Jan 30, 2025 10:25 AM EST reply actions  

Burch did improve, but not enough lately

My most common defense of Marc Burch in the past was that he improved at left back every year since moving there. That was true in 2007, and it was true in 2008. But it was unfortunately not true in 2009. If he has indeed reached his plateau, then it’s time for a change.

Wallace and Pontius were both used in many different roles during 2009. Seems pretty likely that each will be trusted with being a regular starter at a single position in 2010.

by Martin Shatzer on Jan 30, 2025 11:18 AM EST up reply actions  

Burch improved slightly.

But not by much. He was inconsistent as a defender but remember, he learning on the job. he was a left Mid at MD. I agree that Wallace may be no worse and bring the speed and athleticism. The one thing that Burch does well, and I wouldn’t argue that he should keep the job because of this, is that he crosses very well. Jason Garey should give half his rookie salary to Burch since it was Burch that served up all those crosses to Garey his senior year. I remember watching that and wanting Burch as much as Garey. What I didn’t realize is how it would all translate to the pros. We should definitely send Wallace to the back left and keep Burch around to back him up. We may need Wallace’s speed on the wing if Castillo struggles/gets carded/gets injured.
what i want to see as well is some of Wallace’s attacking skills from the left back position. If he can get a bit more forward than Burch (assuming he has better speed to recover), than that allows Castillo to be effective from a more forward position. It’s encouraging to think we could sustain that kind of an attack. Onalfo has already said that it will be a 4 man backline. So I’m curius who the right will be (if Namoff isn’t better) and who the other central defender will be.

I’m still curious who will be the Central Mid. Sounds like you like Szetela in that spot?

by monk81 on Jan 30, 2025 2:02 PM EST up reply actions  

Burch is undoubtedly a better crosser than Wallace, but his lack of mobility means that everyone knows what’s coming when he gets the ball 40 yards out. He’s either playing the deep cross, or he’s playing a sideways pass (usually, he’s pretty good about getting his head up and seeing how the numbers in the box are). Even when we get a good situation for Burch to cross, the fact that he never comes down the wing means that it’s always the same angle. Wallace may not be as accurate, and he may struggle to curl his crosses around players that are trying to close him down, but the fact that he will get to deeper positions and can dribble in instead of cross makes him a more confusing threat.

As for filling out the back four, I think the other center back has to be James if we make no other signings. Burch, McTavish, and Simms are all pretty shaky there, and in the case of Simms he’s also far and away our best option at defensive midfield. N’Galula is totally unproven, and Graye has said he’s probably better wide (on top of being another unproven player at MLS level). We should be making at least one center back signing, but if there was a game today it would be James or bust.

On the right, there is going to be a lot of competition to be Namoff’s backup (or replacement, if the worst-case scenario plays out). Vaughn was a solid MLS right back until his injury problems, McTavish played there in college, Graye was UNC’s right back throughout his college career, and Lyle Adams is also in camp looking to earn a spot (remember, he was good enough to be our 2nd round pick last year). Will any of them pan out as a solid starter if Namoff needs more time to recover? That’s the big question, but the plus is that we have enough competition there that each player will have to play at his absolute best.

With central midfield, I like Szetela out of our current options. However, I would really like us to aggressively pursue someone else. Szetela will be a very middle-class MLS playmaker, and we need to do better than that. As a backup to another top choice, he’d be very good depth, but as a starter he’s merely the best option due to lack of real competition.

Check back later today, because I’ll be offering up a discussion related to this topic.

by ChestRockwell on Jan 30, 2025 2:49 PM EST up reply actions  

I’d write a full comment, but Chest already nailed it. I agree with everything he said, especially about speed out of the back and ditching the predictability in the attack (“We will march through the center of the park; I don’t care how many bodies they pack in there!”). Of course, if Wallace doesn’t work out at LB, or a more glaring need opens up elsewhere, then Onalfo & Co. will have to reevaluate as the situation dictates.

by The AMT on Jan 30, 2025 10:41 AM EST reply actions  

Off-Topic, but...

I meant to tell you both earlier, congrats on the new digs. Looking forward to see the collab.

by The AMT on Jan 30, 2025 10:41 AM EST reply actions  

Thanks

Nice to see some familiar names like Taylor and Hund starting to show up in my members list :)

by Martin Shatzer on Jan 30, 2025 11:11 AM EST up reply actions  

I’ll second that. If smart people are coming here, and Shatz hasn’t told me to go to hell, I’m happy.

by ChestRockwell on Jan 30, 2025 2:52 PM EST up reply actions  

Yeah, I’m here, lurking in the shadows and bitching to myself about the cookies this site is slinging. ;-). And now to drag us back on topic…

Wallace to left back. In a back four? No brainer when his competition at this point is Burch. I see your defense of him is finally crumbling.

/Mr. Burns finger-steeple…excellent!

by The Fullback on Jan 30, 2025 2:24 PM EST reply actions  

Burch's strong suits

1) He’s got some bite when he defends
2) he can serve a very nice cross
3) he’s one of the few players since Agoos who can send a long cross-field ball accurately.

The problems are as follows.

1) Burch has to be there to do the defending. His lack of speed means he’s chasing the game a lot, esp. when he has gone forward. He’d be much better in a four-man back line than in a three-man back line.

2) He telegraphs his crosses. Everyone on the field and in the stands knows when he’s going to send in a cross. He almost always has to take a touch before hitting a cross. As a result he gets shut down a lot.

3) He can’t pull the trigger quickly enough to make this useful.

I’ve only seen Wallace play LB once and he wasn’t impressive there. I’d like to see him get some extended time there before making a judgement either way. He has good speed, and that’ll help. He’s also capable of overlapping and sending in crosses, as well as cutting into the middle of the field as the situation demands.

I suspect Burch is going to be a backup this year.

by Matt Mathai on Jan 30, 2025 5:33 PM EST reply actions  

Problem #1 is the main thing. Burch is chasing the game physically and mentally. He’s probably fairly close to Namoff in actual speed, but in speed of thought it’s not even close. If Burch was a smarter defender, this would be a very tough decision. I don’t think Wallace will jump in with a noticeably sharper understanding of the position, but he’s fast enough to cover for some positional deficiencies and is enough of an attacking force to keep midfielders honest.

I do, however, worry about Wallace’s penchant for fouling. I had to look this up: Wallace committed 52 fouls in 28 games last year (4th most in MLS). That’s not too bad of a figure per game (1.86), but there were quite a few games where he had given up 4 or 5 fouls. He wasn’t as bad about it as, say, Fred (king of the dumb, useless foul 30 yards from goal), but it was still something of an issue.

by ChestRockwell on Jan 30, 2025 8:52 PM EST up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation fan blog in support of D.C. United!

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Where in Ft. Lauderdale is training camp?
Dsc00683_small
Strikers???
Dsc00683_small
Supplemental draft
Fedora_small
SuperDraft SuperConjecture SuperFuntime!
What, If Anything, Does The MSA Report Tell Us About A New D.C. United Stadium?
Happyhanukkah_small
Danny Allsopp goes waltzing Matilda

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

SBNation.com Recent Stories

+2 updates

Fedor Vs. Silva Results: Press Conference And Post-Fight Notes

+2 updates

Villanova Vs. Pitt: Panthers Hang On For 57-54 Win At The Pavillion

Photo +14 updates

Strikeforce: Fedor Emelianenko Vs. Antonio Silva Results And Live Play-By-Play

More from SBNation.com >


Managers

Martin2_small Martin Shatzer

Authors

Hbsc_small ChestRockwell

Fedora_small The AMT