Ben Olsen Takes Over For Curt Onalfo As D.C. United Head Coach: The Right Decision
12 shutouts in 18 matches.
Really that’s all you need to know.
D.C. United has had its share of injuries this season, just like every other MLS club. But the real long-term injuries were almost exclusively to defensive players. That doesn’t explain 12 shutouts in 18 matches.
United fans have been complaining since February that the team lacks a playmaker and a true striker. Well the front office made strides to correct those issues in July by adding Branko Boskovic and Pablo Hernandez. The team is 0-3 since. So that doesn’t explain 12 shutouts in 18 matches either.
Getting fired after 18 matches is nothing new for Curt Onalfo. His Kansas City Wizards team was 5-6-7 last season when he was let go. Only the pitiful New York Red Bulls had fewer goals at the time. In fact, between 2007-2009 in K.C. and 2010 in D.C., teams coached by Curt Onalfo have scored only 127 goals in 4.5 years. Only one other team in that period has scored fewer - Toronto FC. And if you exclude the 2007 season since Onalfo inherited a Wizards team worthy of 47 goals and TFC was in their first year of existence, Onalfo’s teams have the worst scoring total in MLS.
Onalfo was dismissed from the Wizards on August 3, 2009. This year, he made it one day longer.
The debate that’s raged all season has been whether United’s awful record is the fault of the players, the coach, or team management. Most conclude that it’s a combination of all of the above. Now we’ll at least be able to identify whether or not it was the coach who was solely to blame.
Or will we? There’s also a chance that this is just setting up Curt Onalfo to be the scapegoat. Does anyone else see the future the same as I do?
United’s past two matches have been losses to the best two teams in the league. Before that was a loss to the Seattle Sounders. They’re undefeated in their last seven competitive matches, and we kept them scoreless until the 89th minute.
With those tough matches behind us, I see a soft section of the schedule on the horizon. Matches this month against the New England Revolution, Philadelphia Union, and Chivas USA are all winnable. In their Open Cup victory over the Harrisburg City Islanders and their 4-0 friendly win over Portsmouth FC, D.C. United proved that they know how to score. Newly acquired Boskovic and Hernandez work well together, and Santino Quaranta is probably playing better right now than he has all year. Maybe more importantly, several United players are getting healthy all at once. We may have our best defensive lineup all active for the first time this season with Dejan Jakovic and Rodney Wallace set to rejoin Julius James and Devon McTavish as starters. Chris Pontius will be back as well. The only regular who is currently set to miss time over this period is Clyde Simms. Simms is definitely an important part of our team, but his absence is nothing compared to what we’ve been through earlier in the year.
I see United gaining traction and winning some games in this upcoming portion of the season. And it won’t be just because they eliminated Curt Onalfo, although that may be how it will look.
Ben Olsen getting promoted to interim head coach was the inevitable next step in his illustrious career with the historic franchise. Whether the position will be temporary or permanent will be determined over the next three months, as well as in interviews that will follow the season. Kevin Payne doesn’t seem to intend Olsen to be a permanent solution. But I do agree with the organization that he is the best candidate at this particular moment in time. Some have indicated that Curt Onalfo had lost the locker room. I don’t see that happening under Ben Olsen. Not now, not ever. The players will fight for him, there’s no doubt about that.
If you don’t think Ben Olsen is qualified or ready to take on this role, then ask yourself if you believe that Kris Kelderman, Chad Ashton, or Mark Simpson would be a better choice.
Onalfo’s firing was intended to send a message to the players. 12 shutouts in 18 matches is unacceptable. Kevin Payne’s comments to Steve Goff that "There are very few players who I would say are absolutely safe" is also certainly meant to send a message. Do you think many guys are going to sleep easy tonight? Is this the kind of motivation that you want to hear from a Team President?
There’s one good thing that will surely come out of this move. If you were a long-time fan of D.C. United who was beginning to lose interest in this team (and in this blog!) because of United’s dismal results, welcome back. The next 13 weeks are going to be a fun ride.
Tweet
11 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I give you the shutouts
I thought I would take a look at how RSL’s Jason Kreis did in his first 18 matches, and while RSL was only shut out in 7 of those matches (we did have the 2006 MLS golden boot winner in Jeff Cunningham). RSL went 5-9-4 in the first 18 matches under Jason, which is a couple wins better than DC’s 3-12-3 record, but I would say that the RSL roster was a bit more solid than is DC’s and the change wasn’t just the coach it was the GM and the President of the team. The roster changes started almost immediately with trades with Colorado, Toronto, KC, and LA to bring in names like Findley, Movsisyan, Eskandarian, and then there was the trio of Argies picked up in the summer transfer window, two of whom are still with the team and making a huge impact.
I said it when they hired Curt, that I was surprised that he was their choice. After hearing Kevin Payne say that the team was doing a worldwide search for a coach, the fact that they hired a guy who failed to make the cut in KC, told me that as far as Kevin was likely concerned worldwide meant former players with little experience. I think the issues for DC are not related to the coach, but they are most likely in the hands of the GM and President of the club. It seems like the decline began as soon as the club was sold by AEG, I like Ben Olsen. He is a class act, and nothing was funnier then him laughing his ass off at a Ben Olsen=Geico Caveman sign in 2008, well maybe it was funnier when he wanted his picture taken with it and autographed it. Maybe a player who is closer to the current history of the team will find a way to motivate the players, but to me it seems that to make the changes that it looks like DCU need to make will take a full commitment of the organization to common goals. So far I haven’t heard anything like that.
I knew things were changing at RSL when the owner called a press conference to announce the change of the coach and other positions, so where were Will and Victor?
by denz on Aug 4, 2025 9:41 PM EDT reply actions
All fair points
One thing though: Victor MacFarlane is no longer an owner of DC United. Will Chang is the sole owner.
by Brendanukkah on Aug 5, 2025 8:22 AM EDT up reply actions
So what’s next? The WaPo article on the situation today suggested Bob Bradley. This would be great for two reasons: A) he shouldn’t be the USMNT coach anymore, and B) he’d be a better fit for DCU.
A Capital Wasteland - art & hockey from Washington, D.C.
by Jake Shapiro on Aug 5, 2025 7:36 AM EDT reply actions
I'd take that
Just for Reason A. Coaches all over the world have terrible track records in their second World Cup with the same team.
Detroit4Lyfe
by handsomerob1 on Aug 5, 2025 9:10 AM EDT up reply actions
If Goff says it...
Then I believe it. He’s rarely wrong about these things. He had Caleb Porter as the #1 contender last year before anyone of us knew who he was.
Yeah I’d love Bob Bradley too. But would he want the job?
Managing Editor for BlackAndRedUnited.com. Weekend Writer for SBNation DC.
by Martin Shatzer on Aug 5, 2025 10:27 AM EDT via mobile up reply actions
Well, at least I know I can start getting mad about a sub-optimal starting XI now.
(Yup, I’m still bitter.)
Simulated Gameday Experience - just like the real thing, only we have smoke machines.
by Chris Pendley on Aug 5, 2025 2:04 PM EDT up reply actions
Even if United Keep Sucking
You still get to look forward to watching Andy Najar every game. That is a big plus.
Win or lose, we will always be here for you.
by johnjahafanclub on Aug 5, 2025 10:52 AM EDT reply actions
The way Perkins is playing, we may see Bill Hamid playing every game too. /half snark
It takes...something? Anything?!?
by Bald Pollack on Aug 5, 2025 2:29 PM EDT up reply actions
With the playoffs out of the question
I think we should see Hamid playing every game regardless of how good/bad Perkins is.
Detroit4Lyfe
by handsomerob1 on Aug 5, 2025 9:15 PM EDT up reply actions
I think that's right
what is there to lose at this point? Get him some games under his belt, see what he’s got.
Win or lose, we will always be here for you.
by johnjahafanclub on Aug 6, 2025 11:14 AM EDT up reply actions
Not so sure about that
Kevin Payne’s 3 priorities for the remainder of the season were:
1. Win some games
2. Go a full 90 minutes every match
3. Play for the shirt (whatever that really means)
If Olsen and his assistants think that Perkins gives them the best chance to win each week, he will still be the starter.
Very curious to see who will be in the lineup Saturday night. That will surely set the tone and give us a hint as to what to expect going forward.
Managing Editor for BlackAndRedUnited.com. Weekend Writer for SBNation DC.
by Martin Shatzer on Aug 7, 2025 7:59 AM EDT up reply actions

by Martin Shatzer on 






