D.C. United Loses To Chivas USA, While All Eyes Look Towards Wednesday
Last week against the Philadelphia Union, you wouldn't have guessed that it was a match between the two worst teams in the league. D.C. United didn't exactly look like the champions of years past, but they looked indiscriminately better.
None of that was true tonight though. The last place team in the East was taking on the last place team in the West, and they both looked like exactly. You've got to think that ESPN must be kicking themselves for picking this one to be their "Game of the Week" rather than potential championship matchup of the Columbus Crew against FC Dallas that took place on Saturday.
Neither team really played well. United surely looked like the better side in the second half, but the difference was (as it often is) that Chivas USA finished off one of their few opportunities, and United failed to finish off any of their many.

The reason for United's improved performance in the second half was glaringly obvious - it was Andy Najar. The pace picked up and other players around him raised their levels also. The problem though was that Chivas had already regressed into a shell at the time that Najar entered in the 57th minute, and far too many United players were already gassed.

In his first week back in action after receiving some time on the bench following some really ugly performances, Jordan Graye had one of his better games. He once again looked much more comfortable on the right than on the left. He didn't give up any real chances to Chivas, and was frequently winning headers in the box.
On a few occasions early in the match, Jaime Moreno looked like the best player on the field. He had complete control when on the ball. But that didn't last long. Moreno appeared to have gotten frustrated with his teammates, choosing to attempt to dribble through traffic (which he used to be able to do better than anyone else in the league) rather than seek out a better option. Moreno was frequently dispossessed, and was a nonfactor for most of the second half.
If Chivas had truly earned their goal tonight, I wouldn't feel as bad about this one. But the goal came off a mistake by Troy Perkins, who was too far off his line to have a chance at the save on Justin Braun's lobbed header, and by Barry Rice, who didn't make it hard enough for Braun to put the ball exactly where he wanted it.
I didn't realize when D.C. acquired Branko Boskovic that they were bringing on yet another 60-minute player. I thought that the retirement of Ben Olsen and the waiving of Christian Gomez and Luciano Emilio meant that Moreno was the only attacker left on our rest who mandated a substitution midway through the second half every match. In addition to running out of gas too early, Boskovic had a fairly poor match. His passes didn't connect and he also needed a lot of help from Stephen King on the right side (which come to think of it may have been King's only contribution tonight). I was actually expecting Olsen to swap King and Boskovic midway through the second half since Boskovic was so uninvolved defensively, especially in allowing Ante Jazic such an open cross to Braun for the goal.
Adam Cristman and Santino Quaranta each had underwhelming performances tonight. If soccer was all about running hard, Cristman would be an MVP candidate, but unfortunately his six turnovers (yes, I counted) more than wiped out any good work he performed off the ball. When you don't have good dribbling skills, it's probably best not to try to dribble through your opponents. Quaranta likewise lost the ball far too often, although he was responsible for United's best chance of the night, intentionally shooting the ball off the crossbar and into the back of Zach Thorton's leg so that it would almost ricochet into the goal.
***
Yes, we were all hoping for a better performance and a better result tonight. Especially after such a promising outing last weekend. But keep in perspective that we still have a chance to erase all the bad memories of this season by taking home the U.S. Open Cup. That quest continues Wednesday night at RFK Stadium against the Columbus Crew.
And the good news is that we'll have Bill Hamid and Andy Najar for the entire match.
Tweet
22 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Yeah, Graye’s first start in forever was nice to see.
Disagree to an extent on Tino; while he still was holding onto the ball for one or two touches too long, he seems to be improving on his set piece balls, which in and of itself would seem to be a minor miracle.
"#DCU is like senior prom. A bunch of people standing around waiting for a 17-year old to score."
by Bald Pollack on Aug 30, 2025 8:44 AM EDT reply actions
Yeah, I actually thought Tino was the Man of the Match for DC in this one
He’s looked bad most of the season, but he looked less bad in this one, showing off energy, a helluva dipping shot (still not sure how that didn’t go in), and one or two nice dribbling forays. Of course, he also tried to dribble through multiple defenders a number of times, only to get dispossessed, and did shoot over the bar… again. Still, I’d have him at three stars tonight.
by Brendanukkah on Aug 30, 2025 12:55 PM EDT up reply actions
Morsink cleared the very low bar I have set for him. His passing was actually decent for the most part, and he paid more attention to the flow of the game than to slights from the referee. He actually played the pivot role rather competently.
That said, bring on Wednesday, for the love of god.
by The AMT on Aug 30, 2025 9:57 AM EDT reply actions
Agreed
Morsink was competent and active.
As opposed to his CM partner Stephen King, who must have taken a couple long water breaks during the match, because he disappeared for many stretches.
Managing Editor for BlackAndRedUnited.com. Weekend Writer for SBNation DC.
by Martin Shatzer on Aug 30, 2025 11:27 AM EDT via mobile up reply actions
I’m not sure you can blame Troy for that goal — he was left high and dry on that goal, and had a decent match otherwise. This is the first I’ve really seen of Rice, and he’s definitely not ready for prime time. Zaher also failed to impress.
As for Branko, decent player, but nowhere near DP status. Some nice work, but several ugly turnovers. Speaking of turnovers — you counted Cristman’s; did you count anyone else’s? I’d bet Jaime and Branko gave him a run for his money.
Agree with Bald that Quaranta looked fairly strong. Don’t know what to say about his near miss — I think he’s wearing Peter Brady’s cursed tiki.
by rke on Aug 30, 2025 10:33 AM EDT reply actions
Turnovers
Didn’t count the others. Just started counting Cristman’s because he would try to dribble at defenders every time he got the ball. Cristman has some strengths, but ball skills isn’t one of them. I would have expected the coaches to talk to him about that at halftime, but apparently they didn’t because he had 2 more turnovers in his 7 minutes of action in the second half.
I think you’re right that Moreno was probably close. One turnover early in the match had Moreno fighting a Chivas player for possession on the left flank, then just giving up and hoping for a foul call.
Managing Editor for BlackAndRedUnited.com. Weekend Writer for SBNation DC.
by Martin Shatzer on Aug 30, 2025 11:34 AM EDT via mobile up reply actions
Related to that last part, I remember Boskovic doing something similar along the right side in the first half, and a Chivas defender barely touched him and he oversold the foul. I damn near winced at that one.
"#DCU is like senior prom. A bunch of people standing around waiting for a 17-year old to score."
by Bald Pollack on Aug 30, 2025 1:34 PM EDT up reply actions
Considering that Barry Rice's one supposed strength is in winning headers, then it was an atrocious night for him
He badly marked, then missed the header on Braun’s goal, and then he lost a header in front of Chivas’s goal that resulted in an eye gash. And let’s not forget giving the ball away to Braun directly in front of goal (Braun really should have had three goals), and then coming up empty on two good opportunities in front of Chivas’s goal. I like Rice, but wow was last night one to forget.
by Brendanukkah on Aug 30, 2025 12:58 PM EDT up reply actions
High and dry?
Perkins was about 3 yards too far off his line. He put himself in no man’s land, and what should have been an easy save instead floated over him. When Jazic’s cross came in, Perkins took a couple steps out, apparently anticipating that Braun would want to bring the ball down on his chest or something like that. In any case, a glance at the ball’s path and a glance at Braun’s charging run at it should have informed Perkins to stay put. From my view, this goal was almost entirely on Perkins.
by ChestRockwell on Sep 1, 2025 4:39 PM EDT up reply actions
Agreed on most of your assessment tonight. Disagree on Tino in part, because I felt that he played better as the night wore on (maybe as a result of Andy coming in?). At the very least, he was trying to serve balls in the box, something our team struggles to do. Also, Perkins was too far off his line regardless of Rice’s marking. A keeper is often only as good as his positioning, and it seems like time and time again this season, Troy just doesn’t know where to go. I like Troy, but boy has he been our biggest bust this season or what.
by DCUFaninMissouri on Aug 30, 2025 2:37 PM EDT reply actions
Troy's situation is baffling to me
Before the season started, I looked at how we’d barely missed the playoffs the last two years, and how we’d had very leaky goaltending that let points slip through our fingers throughout those seasons. With Troy, I thought we were getting the best or second best keeper in MLS, and we’d be pretty well set. I guess I should have put more credence into those howlers he turned in with the USMNT.
Very disappointing.
by Brendanukkah on Aug 30, 2025 4:14 PM EDT up reply actions
Was it because of the price paid?
I don’t know, I always thought an SI (even if it was Fred), a draft pick, allocation and money was always a sketchy thing, but in between him and Pontius, you’ve got two guys who have been/will be considered for USMNT and have almost regressed. Almost depressing.
"#DCU is like senior prom. A bunch of people standing around waiting for a 17-year old to score."
by Bald Pollack on Aug 30, 2025 9:34 PM EDT up reply actions
One thing that jumped out at me was during the 2nd half, we played faster than he had all year, we really picked up the pace and took it to Chivas. No one can finish worth a damn, but Chivas looked like they were caught off guard by the speed at which we played. I think Olsen has put his stamp on this team.
by DonCaps819 on Aug 30, 2025 6:33 PM EDT reply actions
we had all year* I really need to proofread.
by DonCaps819 on Aug 30, 2025 6:34 PM EDT up reply actions
Anyone else follow Bill Hamid on Twitter?
He seems to be going through some dark night of the soul. Which would suck under any circumstances, but I want his head straight and clear for Wednesday.
by Brendanukkah on Aug 31, 2025 12:47 AM EDT reply actions
If I was a Twitter pathologist, I’d notice he’s given out his cell number in a tweet and apparently got in trouble with a girlfriend about something. At the end of the day, he’s still a kid, can’t really do much about it.
"#DCU is like senior prom. A bunch of people standing around waiting for a 17-year old to score."
by Bald Pollack on Aug 31, 2025 8:01 AM EDT up reply actions
Tory Off His Line
I’m glad you mentioned the mistake by Troy Perkins. The ESPN commentators totally gave him a pass, even though the replay clearly showed him about 4 yards off his line, allowing the ball to lob in over his head. There was no reason for him to be off his line at that time. Just lack of focus. I’ll be happy to have the kid, Hamid, back in goal for the USOC game on Wednesday. And I completely agree that Najar seemed to inject energy into the team. I noticed that Quaranta all the sudden started making attacking runs with and without the ball when Najar came on. It’ll be nice to have Najar for a full 80 or 90 on Wednesday. It’s amazing that DC’s chances for victory dramatically increase with a couple of kids in the lineup.
by madavis on Aug 31, 2025 7:31 PM EDT reply actions
Will they both be back in 2011?
I love watching Najar play. Do you think Najar and Hamid will be back next year? It sounds like Arsenal and other European clubs are interested in him.
It would be a big payday for both Najar and D.C. United despite the probability he would be riding the bench for long stretches in Europe.
by Dizzo on Aug 31, 2025 9:10 PM EDT up reply actions
Not sure
Najar will leave sooner or later, and I would say Najar is too young to go anywhere, but with the EPLs new “homegrown player rule” there is some benefit for an English club to land him before he turns 18. Hamid, being a goalkeeper, is probably a safer bet to be around next year. Najar could be gone if someone is willing to take a chance on him. It would be a gamble, but some team in Europe could bring him into their youth system and hope he’s ready to make a real contribution on the senior team in a few years. I’m not sure how I feel about that if Najar decides to wear the US jersey at the international level. If he stays in MLS, he will get good playing time in important games now.
by madavis on Aug 31, 2025 9:30 PM EDT reply actions
Quaranta, Najar, Boskovic
I thought Tino was the best player on either team. Granted, it was a sloppy game in which only a few players were anything other than bad, but still. Quaranta was the player driving us forward, he was involved in virtually every chance we created, and he took on a real “lead by example” role. That run of his in the 64th minute (in which he beat three Chivas defenders to set up Najar) might have been one of our best individual moments of skill all season. It’s not his fault we don’t have any finishers.
Najar created some danger with his speed, but he couldn’t close the deal. Within 7 minutes of coming in, he had 2 real chances to either score or set someone up for a tap-in inside the 6. On the first one, he made the wrong decision (shooting with the outside of his foot on one instead of either using his instep to curl the ball to the back post or passing for Boskovic, who would have had to do a Kamara to miss), and the second was simply a poor shot (he came around the ball so much that his shot actually went out for a throw in). I give him credit for stretching Chivas out, but to me this wasn’t Najar’s best performance.
Finally, Boskovic had a mostly dreadful night. Maybe it was the cross-country trip? If so, then Montenegro is going to be plenty unhappy when he more than doubles that distance in his flight out there for Euro 2012 qualifying. It seemed like Boskovic did OK whenever he took no more than two touches, but anything more than that and he was immediately stripped of the ball or his pass ended up going astray. In the 2nd half, his only contribution came in making a few good back post runs that went unrewarded. With the ball, he seemed half asleep. I’m not entirely surprised by his lack of fitness, since he never got an appropriate preseason (and let’s not kid ourselves, the work he’s getting right now isn’t a replacement for it). I am, however, troubled by the fact that he seems to be regressing.
by ChestRockwell on Sep 1, 2025 4:59 PM EDT reply actions
You're right about Quaranta with one exception
He can blame himself for being one of the poor finishers on the team. He just loves to blast the ball over the net.
by Brendanukkah on Sep 1, 2025 11:29 PM EDT up reply actions

by Martin Shatzer on 






