Black And Red United: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook

SBNhanced MLS Award Tracking: September 2010

Ezra Shaw - Getty Images

Fredy Montero should be the MLS MVP

The MLS season is more than two-thirds complete. The Power Rankings have been fairly stable for weeks. So it's time to mix things up here.

The SB Nation soccer writers gathered together this week in a most virtual manner to go beyond just the teams, and to dive deeper into the MLS statistics. We discussed the upcoming MLS Player Awards. Yeah, we went there!

Each of the seven participating writers submitted three votes in all of the MLS Award categories. A first place vote counted for three points, second place two, and third place one. The results, with requisite commentary, are below. (Note - every player with at least two points is included. Players with only one point just don't belong.)

Most Valuable Player:
1. Fredy Montero, 14
2. David Ferreira, 12
T3. Dwayne De Rosario and Edson Buddle, 5
5. Javier Morales, 3
6. Landon Donovan, 2

Looking at this list just makes me wish that we had voted for these awards earlier. The July voting surely would have seen Donovan and Buddle each in the top three, probably with a couple other Los Angeles Galaxy players mixed in for good measure. But with the Seattle Sounders and FC Dallas each boasting long undefeated streaks, it's no surprise to see their attacking leaders at the top.

Read on for more awards.

Star-divide

Defender of the Year
1. Omar Gonzalez, 15

2. Jamison Olave, 13
3. Osvaldo Alonso, 6
T4. Chad Marshall and Ugo Ihemelu, 2

Gonzalez doesn't know the meaning of a sophomore slump, and he's a big reason for LA's early season dominance. The Galaxy and Real Salt Lake have only given up 16 goals on the season, so finding their top defenders sitting above the rest sounds about right. The fact that a defensive midfielder made this list is a testament to how important Alonso has been for Seattle this season.

Goalkeeper of the Year
1. Nick Rimando, 18

2. Donovan Ricketts, 11
3. Kevin Hartman, 6
T4. William Hesmer and Jimmy Nielsen, 3

Again, hold the voting two months ago and we're talking a totally different story. Ricketts was clearly the best goalkeeper in the league for the first half of the season, but the Galaxy's recent struggles have created some questions. Rimando, on the other hand, has been a consistently excellent shot stopper. The guy has been on his game this year.

Coach of the Year
1. Schellas Hyndman, 16
2. Jason Kreis, 14
3. Bruce Arena, 5
4. Robert Warzycha, 4
5. Hans Backe, 2

Nobody picked Dallas to compete for the Supporters' Shield. But they're doing it. And Hyndman has played a bit role in that. He's got all his guys playing together, with an undoubtedly lower payroll and arguably less talent from top to bottom than roughly half the clubs in MLS.

Rookie of the Year
1. Danny Mwanga, 21
2. Andy Najar, 11
3. Tim Ream, 4
4. Michael Stephens, 3

This is the only unanimous award, and it's for good reason. Thank God for the scoring ferocity of Danny Mwanga, because I really didn't want to have to come on here and write about the overrated Ream. In second place, it's nice to see some national recognition for D.C. United's lone bright spot in their otherwise awful season.

Newcomer of the Year
1. Alvaro Saborio, 20

T2. Jimmy Nielsen and Joel Lindpere, 7
T4. Ryan Smith and Marko Perovic, 4

Here's another award that wasn't even close. Saborio has been a great find for RSL, and amid all the big designated player signings, he has proven to be the best new addition to MLS this year. To round out the competition though, notice a theme? Four Europeans. I guess they're pretty good at soccer afterall.

Comeback Player of the Year
1.
Sebastien Le Toux, 13
2. Bobby Convey, 10
3. Kevin Hartman, 6
4. Bouna Coundoul, 5
5. Chris Albright, 3
6. Dan Gargan, 2

Taking the lead in the most ambiguous award category is the well-rounded Le Toux (9 goals, 9 assists). Full disclosure: I didn't vote for Le Toux because I wasn't really sure he qualified for the award since he appeared in some 20 matches last season. But the guy has clearly taken his game to another level with the Philadelphia Union. Convey is an example of another guy who has rescued a career that was previously left for dead.

That's it for now. Tune in again Oct. 1 for the next round of voting as we continue to track the MLS Player Awards for 2010.

Tweet Comment 8 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

More from Black And Red United

D.C. United To Decide On Charlie Davies Soon

Feb 2011 by Martin Shatzer - 7 comments

D.C. United Reports From Training Camp

Feb 2011 by Martin Shatzer - 7 comments

D.C. United Vs. Akron Zips: A Simulated Friendly

Jan 2011 by Martin Shatzer - 4 comments

Around SB Nation

Seattle Sounders' Three-Year Window - It started in 2010

Feb 2011 from Sounder At Heart - 14 comments

Travel Team To Corpus Christi

Feb 2011 from Big D Soccer - 3 comments

Stephane Auvray Is The Key To Sporting KC's Success

Feb 2011 from The Daily Wiz - 1 comment

Le Toux, Mwanga On Target in 2-0 Preseason Friendly Win Over USF

Feb 2011 from Brotherly Game - 0 comments

Seattle Sounders Vs. Columbus Crew Preseason GameThread

Feb 2011 from Sounder At Heart - 39 comments

Comments

Display:

I'm a little surprised that Backe didn't get more votes for COY

Even before his heavy-duty roster additions, he had last year’s train wreck looking like this year’s porche (or Volvo, I guess, but I’m not sure that has the same cache as a metaphor) with not all that many personnel changes.

by Nevtelen on Sep 1, 2025 11:22 AM EDT reply actions  

Me too - he deserves it

I think most of us were stuck in a box looking at the coaches from only the top 4 teams. I know I was. Backe probably deserves to be #3 behind Kreis and Hyndman.

Managing Editor for BlackAndRedUnited.com. Weekend Writer for SBNation DC.

by Martin Shatzer on Sep 1, 2025 1:20 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions  

Comeback

I really struggled to come up with 3 people to vote for in the comeback category, since previous winners of that award had always been returning from some major injury.

I’m the joker that voted for Albright and Gargan. Albright had 2 different knee surgeries last year and is on the wrong side of 30, but recovered to become a reliable starter for NY. He was the only person that followed the traditional Comeback Player of the Year script. Gargan, meanwhile, had dropped out of MLS for a couple of years before being signed by Toronto this season. He’s now the most (only?) reliable defender Preki can call on.

I have no idea what Le Toux came back from. He wasn’t hurt, and he played frequently last year in MLS. It’s not like Seattle shipped him off for a bag of balls; he was taken in the expansion draft. If Philly hadn’t taken him, I’m sure he’d still be a regular in Seattle. I don’t even see him as eligible for this award, but then it’s an award in which I’m not even sure what qualifies you as eligible.

by ChestRockwell on Sep 1, 2025 4:32 PM EDT reply actions  

He went from being a 1 goal scorer

to a possible MVP if his team was any good.

I am not a Supporter | I am not a Fan | I am a Sounder
Sounder At Heart

by Dave Clark on Sep 1, 2025 5:25 PM EDT up reply actions  

Correct

But I’m still not sure that is what the award is intended to be. Chest is right - the award usually goes to a player who missed lots of time recently with injuries. I think Convey also qualifies because his professional career was basically over a year ago, and now he’s one of the top wingers in the league. Coundoul would also be a good choice.

Managing Editor for BlackAndRedUnited.com. Weekend Writer for SBNation DC.

by Martin Shatzer on Sep 2, 2025 2:17 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions  

By the way

My third place vote for this award was Marc Burch. I was struggling for ideas too.

Managing Editor for BlackAndRedUnited.com. Weekend Writer for SBNation DC.

by Martin Shatzer on Sep 2, 2025 2:21 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions  

I actually don't like the "hey they are healthy" again nature of the award

I prefer guys that were good, had a bad season, or two, or three and then have a good one.

I am not a Supporter | I am not a Fan | I am a Sounder
Sounder At Heart

by Dave Clark on Sep 3, 2025 9:09 PM EDT up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation fan blog in support of D.C. United!

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Where in Ft. Lauderdale is training camp?
Dsc00683_small
Strikers???
Dsc00683_small
Supplemental draft
Fedora_small
SuperDraft SuperConjecture SuperFuntime!
What, If Anything, Does The MSA Report Tell Us About A New D.C. United Stadium?
Happyhanukkah_small
Danny Allsopp goes waltzing Matilda

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

SBNation.com Recent Stories

+2 updates

Fedor Vs. Silva Results: Press Conference And Post-Fight Notes

+2 updates

Villanova Vs. Pitt: Panthers Hang On For 57-54 Win At The Pavillion

Photo +14 updates

Strikeforce: Fedor Emelianenko Vs. Antonio Silva Results And Live Play-By-Play

More from SBNation.com >


Managers

Martin2_small Martin Shatzer

Authors

Hbsc_small ChestRockwell

Fedora_small The AMT