Even more new trialists for United
You're probably getting used to this. United heads to _______, a couple guys leave camp, and a couple more arrive. It came as no shock, then, to see that DC's trip to Torreon, Mexico brought with it news that the club now has Juan Manuel Peña, Daniel Woolard, and (finally) Jermaine Taylor on trial. It was also announced that Shintaro Harada's trial is now over, and that former University of Kentucky center back Barry Rice's trial has continued south of the border.
Why am I cautiously optimistic about the addition of a 37 year old center back and a Fire reject? You know how to find out:
I'll start with the big name of the group, Juan Manuel Peña. Like Jaime Moreno and Marco Etcheverry, Peña is a product of Bolivia's famed Tahuichi Academy. In terms of experience, Peña is beyond reproach. He's got over 300 league games in La Liga, between his time at Real Valladolid and Villarreal, and most recently was at Celta de Vigo of the Spanish 2nd division. He also has 85 caps with Bolivia (at least some of which were as captain), including 3 starts in the most recent World Cup qualifying cycle. However, he ended his time with Celta by retiring this past November.
There will be plenty of MLS fans who read Peña's age and conclude that he will be washed up. I specifically chose the picture accompanying this post as a counter-argument to that; that's Peña, in a World Cup qualifier last year, defending Leo Messi. 37 is old for a soccer player, no doubt, but let's not judge the man entirely on that. Let's not forget that, at 38, Claudio Suarez joined Chivas USA and did pretty well in his first season. Old players lose some athletic ability, but this hurts attackers much more than defenders.
My point is that, when you have a guy with this kind of experience, who was only months ago still playing at a roughly MLS-equivalent level, you give him an honest look. We've all been crying out for United to find an experienced defensive leader for a long time, and Peña fits the bill. Will he adjust to MLS? Did he stay fit in retirement? I have no idea, but I know we're talking about someone that has faced the best in the world for club and country more recently than most MLS players have. If he's arriving in camp fit and serious about finding success in DC, then I wouldn't bet against him. There is the potential that this is exactly what we need; there's also the potential that Peña will be another Duilio Davino. Let's all hope for the former.
We also have two smaller names on trial. B&RU; has already covered Jermaine Taylor, so I'll instead focus on Daniel Woolard. Around these parts, he may best be remembered as Chicago's goalscorer on the night Cuauhtemoc Blanco punched Clyde Simms and headbutted a United staffer. Woolard was taken by the Fire in the 2007 Supplemental draft, and managed 6 starts and 10 substitute appearances in MLS play over 3 seasons before being let go a few weeks ago. That's not a particularly impressive record by itself, but it should be noted that his competition for playing time at left back was Gonzalo Segares, who was among MLS's best left backs during his time here. I also was kind of happy to read that Woolard's lone MLS goal came against New York.
From the times I've seen him play (in person at the aforementioned USOC match and a couple times for the Fire in league play), I always envied Chicago for having a guy like Woolard buried down their bench. He's by no means brilliant, but there are guys starting in MLS at left back that are worse. He's got decent speed and likes to get forward, but he's not reckless about it. I was surprised when Chicago let him go, but it could have something to do with the fact that he's now too old to put on the developmental roster. At the very worst, Woolard will be stern competition for Lyle Adams, who seems to have impressed to at least some degree in this preseason. If he doesn't latch on here (and the possibility of having to trade Chicago something for his rights may hurt), you can expect to see Woolard find work somewhere else in MLS or starting on a 2nd division team.
Moving on to the rest of the news, I can't say I'm surprised about Harada's departure. Once Steve Goff said he'd be looked at as a center back, the writing was on the wall. Harada is 5'8" tall, and the list of MLS center backs of that size that have been successful is a short one (Michael Parkhurst was like 5'9"...and that's the entire list). Harada might have had a better chance going on trial as a defensive midfielder or an outside back, but in any case I don't think we just missed out on a diamond in the USL rough, a la Osvaldo Alonso.
It also doesn't seem like a shock that Rice stuck around. Coming out of college undrafted, he'd probably be looking at a developmental deal anywhere in MLS. DC currently has one such spot open, and the way the roster is shaping up points to it going to a defender. I'm not saying he's a shoo-in, but at this point I think the odds aren't that long.
Tweet
9 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
J.M. Pena
C’mon Chest - if you look closely at the picture you will notice the Argie is young Mario Kempes probably several years before his stardom in the Argentina’78.
;)
Actually, I like that the team is giving Pena a tryout, too. We could certainly use some veteran leadership especially with Namoff and Burch out for who knows how long. Shouldn’t cost the team anything to see if Pena can still play.
While we’re stocking the team with ’94 World Cup veterans maybe Chad Ashton can round up Romario on his trip to Brazil. Bebeto? Batistuta?
by garbaggio on Mar 8, 2025 9:13 PM EST reply actions
I might never have mentioned it, but you have one of my favorite internet names.
I’m probably just getting ahead of myself, but my gut says Pena is going to be ready to go. Of course, we’ve been so desperate for an experienced center back that I convinced myself that Roger was going to work out last year. Still, there are a lot of reasons for this to make sense as a good move in the short term (1-2 seasons, max). If Pena can come in and succeed in 2010 and 2011, there is less pressure on Jakovic to be brilliant (giving him room to grow into the player he could become) and James can learn the mental side from a wily veteran that’s seen everything.
by ChestRockwell on Mar 8, 2025 10:18 PM EST up reply actions
$.02
I think we’re getting ahead of ourselves here. Pena had some skills if he was in La Liga, but his playing time was limited at Villareal and he seems to have played in about half the games with his 2nd division side. If he quit in Nov., you have to wonder what kind of shape he’s in. Still, the team is desperate to have a competent 3rd CB — the Janicki disaster last year has to scare the daylights out of the FO — Because James isn’t the most effective defender yet, it would be better still if Pena can beat out James for the starting nod.
Just because Adams hasn’t been given the boot doesn’t mean he’s impressed anyone…unless you have some more info on that. I’m thrilled Rice is still there — I have a great feeling about him, and I’d love to see him get the developmental. On the other hand, Wasson is still with the team, too. Both were excellent college players. The decision may come down to need, rather than which player shows more promise.
To be honest I’m a bit confused about roster status for players like Wallace (Is he still GA? If not who are the 3 developmental players (Hamid, Graye and ?)? Also, looking at national status — anyone know what Morsink’s status is? Costa Rican native, but USA academics — I’m guessing he’s a domestic player. What’s Wallace’s status? Are we at 5 or 6 internationals (Castillo, Allsopp, Shipilane, Jakovic, Khumalo and ?)? I’m wondering if there’s room for Pena or Taylor (I’m guessing the team is hoping for one but not both) and a Brazilian still to come? I wonder if the team’s struggles to find defenders didn’t play into the decision to release N’Galula — not just to free up $$, but also an international slot for a defender (the team seemed to see Flo as a D-Mid, not a back).
I’m still hoping the team brings in a DP-calibre signing after the Cup (I’m not expecting Ashton to bring one with him). They might have to cut a foreign player loose (perhaps either Tiyi or Boyzzz) to make that happen.
Before I offer an opinion on any of the above-mentioned players, I’d actually like to see them play. @Charleston, I guess.
by fischy on Mar 10, 2025 12:40 AM EST reply actions
Glad you’re commenting here, fischy.
I don’t think it’s too optimistic to just say Pena deserves a real shot at the team. My post on him is more of a counter to the knee-jerk reactions I read elsewhere (“old man, not interested!”). He was in and out of the Villarreal team, but this was a Villarreal team in the top half of as strong a league as there is. Perhaps he went to Celta and the manager was settling for him, or perhaps he was up against another comparable player. I have no idea what went on there. My thoughts, basically, are that 37 isn’t always washed up, especially when we’re talking about defenders. I’m more optimistic because of Pena’s profile (experience, top-level play, Bolivian) and our needs than I am about any specific knowledge about him. I hope he works out, or some other experienced center back arrives.
I have no special info on Adams, but I have noticed that he’s playing more in the friendlies. There’s also the fact that, at the moment, our only option at left back is Wallace. With Burch out 4 months, and no other options on the roster, Onalfo has to pick up either Adams, Graye, or some other guy that isn’t in camp at this point. My hunch is that we sign Adams to a senior minimum deal (since he was unwilling to take a developmental deal last year) and cut Shipalane (who is redundant at right midfield, where about half the roster can play). Wasson did also have a couple games of left back experience with the Rapids, but he was sitting out friendlies in favor of Andy Najar. I just don’t see any evidence from our friendlies that Onalfo wants him.
To answer your roster questions: Wallace is no longer a GA. Our 3 developmental players are Hamid (GA), Barklage, and DiRaimondo (though Goff has said he’s essentially on trial in camp, he was never actually cut or waived, so I assume his contract status from last year technically remains in effect). Graye is unsigned at this point; we just have his MLS rights. Morsink is a dual Costa Rican/American citizen (scroll to the bottom). Wallace is a green card holder, so he’s in the clear as far as the international roster. That roster, from what I can tell, is at 6 players: James, Jakovic, Allsopp, Castillo, Khumalo, and Shipalane. Again, I see Shipalane as expendable, so if Ashton comes back with a signing and Pena or Taylor get signed, we’ll be down to one South African. I would imagine one factor in N’Galula’s release was the fact that we’re down to 7 international slots, but my guess is that it was more about Onalfo not being impressed by how he fits the system we’ll be using. Otherwise, we don’t bother with Morsink.
I’m definitely with you on the need for a big talent. I see the current team (assuming a center back of some kind is signed) as probably somewhere between 7th and 12th. We won’t suck like NY or SJ last year, but making the playoffs will be tough. This team needs a central midfielder of top-tier ability to control the tempo and serve as the true danger man in our lineup. We have a lot of good parts, but I think we are in need of one true standout to bring the best out of those collected pieces.
by ChestRockwell on Mar 10, 2025 4:36 AM EST up reply actions
Glad to be here
Thanks for the reply and info. Y’know — I had Wasson confused with the guy they brought in at the same time — Otto Loewy. Wasson can’t get a developmental slot — too old. Still , United could use his experience (it’s not much, but compared to the competition…), and his USA citizenship. I won’t be entirely surprised if he makes it, especially in place of Tiyi. I wouldn’t read too much into the early playing time. Najar got a lot of time early on, because they wanted to get him some experience. Now, they’re looking at the guys they’ll need this year. Didn’t realize DiRai wasn’t on the senior roster. I guess that probably helps his chances of sticking. I agree with you that Graye and Adams will probably make the final cut. I haven’t ruled out Tiyi yet — especially with Tino now in the middle and Szetela just getting his toes wet, we could use someone on the right. It could shake out in ways that will surprise us all.
by fischy on Mar 10, 2025 11:11 AM EST up reply actions
Also glad to see some of the SI regulars giving us a look.
Fischy, if you haven’t yet, check out the rolling roster posts, which has our best attempt at defining the roster status of each player. One of the big questions though is the international status of Adams. That could throw a wrench into some of our other plans.
My thoughts on Pena? I guess I generally trust the coaching staff to evaluate a guy’s fitness level and find out whether or not he has kept in shape. Chest is right that we don’t give up anything by giving him a trial, so we’ll learn soon enough if he’s still got what it takes. If Pena makes the team, I don’t think he would necessarily be an automatic starter at CB. Pena and James seem to be very different players with very different experience levels, so I could see us using either one of them depending on the situation.
by Martin Shatzer on Mar 10, 2025 6:37 AM EST up reply actions
On Pena
I’m not suggesting he is an automatic starter. On the other hand, I’m not sure he signs on unless he’s given some assurance about playing time. I don’t have any insight other than that it seems his temporary retirement was tied either to lowball contract offers or lack of playing time — or both.
by fischy on Mar 10, 2025 11:14 AM EST reply actions
Thanks
Thanks for the compliments on the internet nickname. I’ve been using it on several discussion boards since Roberto Baggio was still playing. I’m Joel Lane on Goff’s Soccer Insider but their software now recognizes folks by their original Washington Post log-in identities.
Any insights on last night’s game at Santos?
by garbaggio on Mar 11, 2025 10:35 AM EST reply actions
That, and a look at Columbus and Toronto, are coming soon. Gotta hit the gym first though.
by ChestRockwell on Mar 11, 2025 5:06 PM EST up reply actions









