D.C. United Signs Argentine Center Back Emiliano Dudar
After an almost silent offseason, D.C. United has been adding players at a fairly reliable rate since the various MLS drafts were completed. That trend continued today, as United officially announced the signing of Emiliano Dudar. Dudar, who had been rumored to be a DC target for weeks, is a 30 year old Argentine center back with experience at big clubs in Argentina, Brazil, and Switzerland, and comes to United from Swiss side Young Boys BSC.
What jumps out immediately about Dudar is his size: At 6'4" and 198 lbs, he is immediately among the biggest players in MLS. For a United side that has often been noted as a smaller team physically, a player like Dudar fits in with what appears to be an offseason strategy to become bigger and stronger. Dudar is the third player standing 6' tall or higher to join United since the 2011 season ended (along with Robbie Russell and Maicon Santos).
Dudar's time with Young Boys had some ups and downs. The ups include winning the 2009-2010 Swiss Defender of the Year award in his first season with the club, as well as extensive experience in the Europa League. On the down side, Dudar suffered a severe concussion that required being placed in a medically-induced coma for a short while.
According to Steve Goff, United put Dudar through a thorough series of tests before signing him. Given the club's history with concussed players, you'd have to imagine that they wouldn't have signed Dudar unless he got an all-clear on the medical side.
Unlike numerous past seasons during the Dave Kasper era, where United usually carried just three true center backs and would always find themselves short at some point due to injuries and suspensions, the club had made it a priority to have four guys capable of starting at center back in MLS. Bringing Dudar aboard means, at the very least, that guys like Russell or Perry Kitchen won't be dragged out of position the first time we have an injury or red card at the position.
This is no small deal when you consider that Dejan Jakovic has had hamstring troubles throughout his United career; that Brandon McDonald has also picked up injuries here and there during his MLS career; and that Ethan White is currently not able to train as he recovers from an offseason PCL tear. We don't have the most durable group of center backs, in other words, so adding a fourth was a smart move (provided, of course, that he can actually play at a good enough level).
Dudar, if he's any kind of real professional, will be coming in looking to fight his way into a starting job. While most would agree that McDonald is our strongest center back, Dudar might not automatically be trying to push Jakovic out of the other starting role. If Dudar is not particularly fast or quick, it might be problematic to start him alongside McDonald as opposed to pairing him with Jakovic, who is one of the faster center backs in MLS. While certain teams won't make it much of a problem - Houston using two target men, for example, or Chivas playing a forward pairing with a combined age of nearly 70 - most clubs in this league will punish a lack of speed in the back. It will be very interesting to see what we can find out in the preseason as far as what pairing emerges as the best overall.
Adding Dudar also means Ben Olsen can consider using McDonald in a defensive midfield role. It's not the ideal position for him, but he has more experience there than Stephen King and has done better there in the past than Kurt Morsink ever has. With Kitchen's likely Olympic involvement - he's not in the current camp because a case of turf toe prevented him from training at 100% until this week, but he'll almost certainly get called in for the qualifying tournament - this is a significant positive. We may see McDonald in that role as early as the first game of the season, depending on how flexible Caleb Porter is with his Olympic qualifying call-ups.
Both United's official announcement and Goff's piece on the signing note Dudar's leadership qualities. This goes with another trend in the club's offseason moves, as Russell was also noted as a leader during his time with Real Salt Lake. On a team that features plenty of young regulars, that kind of quality is always going to help.
24 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Great Signing (on paper)
Great signing as I am hugely optimistic about him. Size, technical ability, experience… sounds good.
just thinking with now what to do with McDonald and Jakovic. I love McDonald cus of his athletism, but I honestly think Jakovic is a better cetter back. Jakovic will be out a lot with hamstring issues and Canadian duty so I still see McDonald playing center back a lot this year, but I think the best pairing will be Jakovic and Dudar. Nevertheless look at this possible 4231.
Hamid
Russel, Jakovic, Dudar, Woolard (or new signing)
McDonald, Kitchen
Najar, Boskovic, Pontius
DeRo
now THAT defense looks nasty! rising future USMT goalkeeper who’s a beast, proven MLS right back with championship, big fast Canadian international entering his 4th year and is his time to shine if stays healthy, 6’4 experienced (only 30… not 37 lol) technical Argentine that was named the Swiss league defender of the year not long ago, durable hardworking defender/or new hopeful signing
and infront of that the defensive midfield pairing of the 20 year old 2011 ROTY runner up that logged the most minutes last season AND a big athletic agressive motivated 26 year old that was award a new contract
I might just be getting ahead of myself but that looks pretty damn good in my opinion. It would be VERY difficult for teams to penetrate that defense. I’f this possibly occurs, I see the leaky goals ending and a lot of shutouts this season
Now whats in front of that rock defense
it really doesn’t matter. just let DeRo be DeRo, Najar be Najar, and Pontius be Pontius. Goals will occur with them in there and we will only need 1 or 2 to secure a win (instead of needing 3 or so) . And in this Boskovic will have less need to defend which would relinquish a lot of pressure and hopefully let us see what he can actually do.
also the options are endless. If we need more attack we can pull McDonald out and put in Santos, or Wolf, or BB. Or pull McDonald out and put Deleon on and Pontius up top, or Cruz in and Najar up top. Or pull Bosko and put Dero as the attacking center mid. Or King in. Etc…
I’m very excited how this team looks and am eager to sea how it all comes together. In my opinion, the left back position is the only thing. If we get a solid left back that can attack and cross well, were golden
by dcunitedfan100 on Jan 25, 2012 8:27 PM EST up reply actions
It's a good thing that DCU has started acquiring some depth
For a team that hasn’t had to deal with many international call-ups for the last few years, we face losing Hamid and Kitchen for long stretches. Najar, hopefully, won’t be gone as long — I say, hopefully, mostly because I’m hoping the USA qualifies over Honduras for the London Games. We also face losing Boskovic for the Euro championships. We might even see White called up to the U23s, when he’s healthy. And, we will lose DeRo and Jakovic for Canada’s qualifying. It’s not totally out of the question that Pontius will get a call-up for the USA, depending on how he does when he returns.
Montenegro...
Lost its qualification playoff tie to the Czech Republic.
by Karlito Vargas on Jan 26, 2012 12:23 AM EST up reply actions
Boskovic may still miss games
Montenegro will start World Cup qualifying in the fall. The relevant dates for us are:
9/7: home vs. Poland
9/11: away vs. San Marino (might be able to persuade the coach to release him for that one, as there are numerous DC-area amateur teams that would beat San Marino)
10/16: away vs. Ukraine
11/14: home vs. San Marino (see above)
The good news is that we have a 2 week break from 9/1 to 9/15. If some friendly chats between Olsen and Montenegro’s coach go well, we shouldn’t miss him for any matches in September. However, the game against Ukraine will probably mean we’ll be without Boskovic for our 10/20 home game against Columbus, which will probably be a very big game for both teams. Maybe – and this is a stretch – but maybe he’ll be recovered enough from playing and the long flight to make the bench.
I would hope strongly that Montenegro’s coach would let him stay here during the playoffs (assuming we make them) rather than forcing him to fly out for their other game against Montenegro.
Writer on SBN's DC United blog Black and Red United | @ChestRockwell14 | KEEP UNITED IN DC
by ChestRockwell on Jan 26, 2012 7:00 PM EST up reply actions
Good point
Cautiously optimistic given the talk coming out of United camp about his fitness and dedication, but there are still plenty of things going on there. What if he does earn a new deal, but United only wants 1 DP (assuming De Ro gets the deal he’s earned)? Will he stay for 75% or so of his current salary? That would get him under the DP threshold.
Writer on SBN's DC United blog Black and Red United | @ChestRockwell14 | KEEP UNITED IN DC
by ChestRockwell on Jan 27, 2012 11:44 AM EST up reply actions
What if...
United only wants 1 DP and Boskovic is outperforming De Rosario.
Many of us have really high hopes for both of them this year. But if Boskovic lives up to his potential, and DeRo finally starts to show his age and takes a step back, we could see another tough decision this summer. I feel like the United front office is pretty much in agreement that they kept Jaime Moreno here one year too long. They’ll be wary to do the same thing with DeRo.
Managing Editor for BlackAndRedUnited.com. Weekly Columnist for SB Nation D.C..
by Martin Shatzer on Jan 28, 2012 4:40 PM EST up reply actions
Wait wait wait wait wait.
Is centerback DCU’s strongest position now? Or is it still winger?
Dudar, McDonald, Jakovic, White, Rodriguez, Kitchen all can play centerback and I wouldn’t stress out if any of them start.
Still winger
Dudar is an unknown, and White would still have 1 more year of college eligibility if he had stayed at Maryland. Cruz, meanwhile, started for the MLS Cup runner-up and DeLeon was the star man on one of the top 10 NCAA teams this past year.
It is nice for once to have what appears to be depth at center back, though.
Writer on SBN's DC United blog Black and Red United | @ChestRockwell14 | KEEP UNITED IN DC
by ChestRockwell on Jan 25, 2012 8:47 PM EST up reply actions
Well....
I’ll give you Najar and Pontius on the wing…since they’re two of the best wingers in MLS. For argument’s sake — since you corrected me on the timing of Jakovic’s injury — Cruz wasn’t much of a starter. He started 3 of Houston’s last 13 regular season games, when the team was fighting for a playoff spot and put together a long unbeaten streak to finish out the season. True, he did start some games — but let’s not get carried away in claiming he was a key piece of that team. As for DeLeon — he was a star for Louisville — though most would say Rolfe was THE star. Moreover, if White had stayed in college, he would have been the top defender on one of the top 10 NCAA teams — but, he was, instead, getting better experience.
I feel I have been one of the most vocal critics of Jakovic since he came on board. It was only in that last stretch he had with the team, before his call-up in August to Canada that I thought I saw a confident and competent defender. I think down the stretch, we saw why San Jose had already replaced McDonald, but he’s still athletic enough to make some great plays. Ditto for Ethan White. We don’t know what Dudar will offer yet, but I feel confident in saying at this point in their respective careers, he’s a far better defender than Cruz and DeLeon are wingers — possibly a better defender than Najar and Pontius are wingers.
I’m inclined to think our central defense will be a strong point, maybe the strong point for the team this year…assuming they can stay healthy.
Cruz, DeLeon, Jakovic, McDonald
I never said he was a key player, but he was first-choice until he tore his quad on a weird-looking play. He was one of Houston’s missing injured players that all came back at roughly the same time down the stretch, propelling them to their unlikely MLS Cup appearance.
On DeLeon, I think it would be safe to say that Ken Lolla will miss him more than Rolfe next year. Rolfe’s a good player too, but DeLeon was the irreplaceable player.
I think Jakovic’s strongest period of play is the time you’re talking about, and it had a lot to do with being paired with McDonald. Having a vocal leader to do more of the thinking was what Jakovic had needed for years in DC. We tried several times to solve the problem, but that Brazilian guy left abruptly (can’t remember his name) and Juan Manuel Pena was never able to get his body out of retirement. It’s so vital for Jakovic to be the all-action defender in a pairing rather than the cerebral one; when paired with Julius James, for example, he had to be the brains, and we bled goals.
I’m not going to jump to any conclusions about Dudar. It would be fantastic if he’s as good at center back as Najar and Pontius are as wingers. Given our recent problems with signing players from abroad, I’d happily take him being equal to Cruz at his job. However, we won’t know that until the season starts (unless there’s some huge fan of the Argentine and Swiss leagues out there that reads this blog).
At this point, I’d say Najar and Pontius are the only 2 special players out of our 8 wingers and center backs. Cruz, Jakovic, and McDonald are reasonable MLS starters, DeLeon and White are promising young players, and Dudar is unproven. If Dudar is a big-time player, then it would be worth reconsidering, but until that is made clear, I’m going with the wingers.
Writer on SBN's DC United blog Black and Red United | @ChestRockwell14 | KEEP UNITED IN DC
by ChestRockwell on Jan 26, 2012 7:16 PM EST up reply actions
Roger
The Brazilian guy’s name was Roger.
by Brendanukkah on Jan 26, 2012 11:32 PM EST up reply actions
Thanks
That was driving me nuts.
Writer on SBN's DC United blog Black and Red United | @ChestRockwell14 | KEEP UNITED IN DC
by ChestRockwell on Jan 27, 2012 11:45 AM EST up reply actions
Never actually joined the team
Roger was brought in to preseason in 2009 with contract talks already under way. He was supposed to be our new center back and defensive leader, had a reasonable reputation and resume.
After about a week in camp, and with the deal virtually done, he abruptly turned tail and left the States, saying that he and his family decided they didn’t want to live in the US.
Writer on SBN's DC United blog Black and Red United | @ChestRockwell14 | KEEP UNITED IN DC
by ChestRockwell on Jan 27, 2012 1:24 PM EST up reply actions
A week? I think it was a day or two
That’s my memory.
Deepest, but not strongest
I can’t consider it our strongest position until we stop giving up so many goals.
Managing Editor for BlackAndRedUnited.com. Weekly Columnist for SB Nation D.C..
by Martin Shatzer on Jan 25, 2012 8:51 PM EST up reply actions














